Showing posts with label How We Got Here. Show all posts
Showing posts with label How We Got Here. Show all posts

Monday, March 27, 2017

How We Got Here - Post 6

The Progressive Era and the Power of the People

The Progressive Era is how America responded to the abuses of the Gilded Age.

Exactly when the Gilded Age ended and the Progressive Era began is, as always, a bit of a historical debate. As I discussed in the last post of this series, progressivism grew in response to the excesses of wealth, so some of its advances had already begun such as the Pendleton Act, American Federation of Labor, and Sherman Anti-Trust Act However, I like to see it as beginning with a gunshot.

Governor Theodore Roosevelt had proven a thorn in the New York republican party leadership with his progressive ideas of reform. Then, Vice President Garret Hobart died, leaving President McKinley in need of a new vice president for his re-election. The party bosses now had a tried and true way to get an unwelcome politician out of the way. They convince Roosevelt to be McKinley's new vice president.. With Roosevelt, McKinley won in a landslide only to be assassinated in his first year. Suddenly, for the first time, against his own party’s efforts, a progressive was the most powerful politician in America.

You might not call President Roosevelt a progressive by the standards of today, but he certainly made steps towards a more progressive government. He argued along, what he would all later the Square Deal, that government had a role in protecting workers and consumers from "predatory wealth”. These sentiments live on within the democratic party, demonstrated when President Obama invoked Roosevelt's famous New Nationalism speech, echoes the words, and made them his own:
"But Roosevelt also knew that the free market has never been a free license to take whatever you want from whoever you can. ...And today, they still can’t. 
"... this country succeeds when everyone gets a fair shot, when everyone does their fair share, and when everyone plays by the same rules ..."
From President Obama’s economic speech in Osawatomie, Kansas.

Starting with the Coal Strike of 1902, President Roosevelt did something not done before, the government took the side of a union. Before when the government got involved, it was to break up a strike taking the stance that the property of the business owner needed to be protected. Instead, President Roosevelt forced both sides to negotiate for the good of the Nation. The precedent was set.

After that, mostly under pressure from the public, activists, and muckrakers, more restrictions on business pass such as the Expediting Act, Elkins Act, Pure Food and Drug Act, and Meat Inspection Act. These were small actions, but they were the beginning of the “regulatory state”.

For the most part, progressive reforms were bipartisan. Each party wanted to do something progressive, they just differentiated on the details, how progressive to be, and who should get credit. That’s where the votes were. Much of the country were those that had been abused by the Gilded Age now, not the ones who prospered. America had been reshaped by immigration, economic turmoil, and technology, but what became of a common thread is this. Most American wanted the government to help them with their problems.

To go over the list of progressive acts and reforms passed would consume more than one post, but up until now, they were limited regulations on business, reforms of government corruption, and the building of public works. This was also the time when 4 significant amendments were passed, the 16th through 19th.

The 16th Amendment made it legal for the Federal Government to collect income tax. You really can’t underestimate the political significant. No one wants to pay taxes, so politics is always about them. However, with such taxes as tariffs, the opposing sides did not depend on wealth but how the wealth was made. Wealthy businessmen wanting fewer imports would use their influence to promote more taxes. However, income tax means the wealthy are always incentivized to use their wealth for lower taxes that can only be countered by populace arguments motivating the masses. Maybe over simplified, but that can sum up most of the political arguments for the last century.

The 17th Amendment made senators elected by democratic vote. This made the lower income voter more significant especially in low population states. Given what we learned in post 1 that seems more significant than it is. However, the number of senators per state did not change, which is what creates the biggest discrepancy. Also, lower income voters had a say before in who their senators were in that they elected the people that voted appointed them. This just made their power more direct. In other words, now senators had to campaign.

The 19th Amendment gave women the right to vote. Obviously, this is the most significant in that it doubled the electorate. But, I’m going to tread lightly here and not say much. I can be stupid, but not stupid enough to claim women vote differently than men without a lot of thought and facts to back me up.

The Progressive Era did have its darker roots, though. Because progressivism includes the idea that science should be used to govern, many progressives advocated eugenics. [1] You will notice that progressives of this era made no opposition to Jim Crow laws. Partly it was political expediency, but it was also because many progressives embraced white supremacy and, even if well meaning, believed social problems required “racial” solutions. For example, President Woodrow Wilson segregated the Federal Government and the Chinese Exclusion Act was renewed. Fortunately, these attitudes only form intent and did not successfully lead to much legislation or permanent effects (which is why you hear so little of it). What it did mean is that while advancement was made for women and the poor, nothing was done for different races.

When progressivism dealt with democratic expansion, civil rights, government corruption, and business greed, it proved successful (at least politically so). It’s when it attempted social engineering problems started. The most visible example is the Temperance Movement and the 18th Amendment. We discussed the Temperance Movement when covering the Jacksonian Era. The movement was apolitical, but more closely aligned with republicans. Besides the fact that much of these movements had, historically, associated themselves with republican abolitionists, the Republican Party chose as a political strategy to promote temperance as an attack against democrats. Most Irish and Germans being democrats, republicans used stereotypes of them to paint the democrats as lacking character.

Progressives embraced temperance based on sociological reasoning. The temperance movement did not just want to ban alcohol because of morality, but a belief that it was the cause of many social ills including familial abuse, unemployment, crime, and so on. [2] (This is also why the Temperance Movement and Suffrage movement became linked. It's not an accident that both amendments were passed next to each other.) Now, we know alcohol can contribute to these problems or be a symptom of a mutual cause, but outlawing alcohol does not cure these problems. It can even make them worse. Prohibition proved a failure to be undone by the 21st Amendment.

Although, the end of the Progressive Era had begun before the beginning of Prohibition. What began the end is what ends most eras, war. Up until now, politicians, for the most part, agreed on what American foreign policy should be. There should be as little as possible. Staying out of other conflicts, especially European, was the consensus, what we would call isolationism today. The Spanish-American War was America's first attempt at imperialism [3], and Americans found they did not like it. [4] But, progressives often viewed foreign affairs as the opportunity, even a responsibility, to make the world better, not just America.

Like it or not, the world had changed, and America, like everyone else, was drawn into WW1. President Wilson delayed America's entrance until the war was almost over, but there are two beliefs about WW1 everyone, even today, agrees with. It should not have happened and it should not happen again. For President Wilson, the second provided the opportunity to apply his theories to prevent war, in particular, the League of Nation.

America wanted no part of it, and the League of Nations failed. Combined with its failure, a post-war economic decline, the death of Theodore Roosevelt [5], and Prohibition, the progressive movement had been mortally wounded. It may not have ended yet, but it did enter a decline.

And then there were the communists. You will remember that during WW1 is when Russia became the first communist state. Fear of communists, bolsheviks, and anarchists had begun when these ideas were first heard of, but the hyper-nationalism brought by WW1, the shock of the Russian Revolution, and terrorist acts done by these leftist groups created what would come to be known as the 1st Red Scare. Hysteria rose beyond the threat, causing deportation and persecution. Within a year, when the predicted Bolshevik revolution did not happen, the panic had faded, but the damage had been done.

Slandering progressivism as communism-lite is not hard. Certainly, if you believe in the most limited government possible, you would inevitably see it that way. However, most of us don’t. But, the communists, Bolsheviks, and anarchists of 1919 made that association all the easier even for those of us not prone to see it. You will still see many conservatives and other groups claim the progressive movement had been “invaded by communists”, and they will point to the 1st Red Scare to justify it.

Ironically, as a progressive, you would not promote a reaction like the 1st Red Scare, realizing you would be its first victim. However, what makes such hysteria more threatening is when it happens with an overpowerful intrusive government, which progressives tend to promote. Then, you see the beginnings of a police state. Fortunately, American has never come anywhere near to being a police state, compared to actual police states, but you can understand the fear.

There is a natural tension in democracies between the needs of the majority versus the rights of individuals. Too much power to the majority and we risk becoming a police state. Too little power, then individuals through wealth and influence become robber barons. The Progressive Era had happened in response to the latter. But, behind that, there was always a fear that the majority would go too far. Perhaps, Prohibitions and the 1st Red Scare were examples of too far. Perhaps not. But, if you know just a little of the history to follow, you know in about twenty years it's going to get a lot scarier.

Monday, February 27, 2017

How We Got Here - Post 5

The Gilded Age: The Origin of the Cult of Wealth

During the Gilded Age, a new "branch" of government formed, big business

After the ending of Reconstruction in 1877, politics started to become familiar with the modern day. State's Rights is ensconced in the Constitution and will never go away, but State's Rights being a preeminent idea had ended. As did slavery. Jim Crow laws would recover some of the political entitlement to white southerners, but never again to that before the Civil War. Instead, a new "branch" of government would be added to the informal five. Big business was now added with the executive, legislative, judicial, press, and states as a power in our democracy. This time would become known as the Gilded Age.[1]

The 2nd Industrial Revolution had begun and with it, a rise in concentrated wealth American had not yet seen. The wealthy of this era we still know today: Carnage, Rockefeller, Vanderbilt, etc. And as always wealthy men become powerful men. Not that this was new to America. However, unlike such men as Washington, Jefferson, and Jackson, these men never sought public office, and their wealth was national in nature. Not plantations, but industrial monopolies that reached across the country: oil, steel, railroad, etc.[2]

This meant that these titans of industry or, as we would come to know them, robber barons had federal power with none of the restraints of democracy. In other words, they were becoming an aristocracy. And worse, they began to embrace it.

Some did rebuff this idea such as Andrew Carnegie, who preferred to see himself as a self-made man. Many of who I'm talking about also preferred that image. (Some even deserved it.) However, the image presented was contradictory. The wealthy insisted that they had obtained their wealth through talent and luck (even those that inherited it), but at the same time, they insisted they were special and deserved special privileges.

Like all aristocracies, they needed an ideology to justify their superiority. America was founded on the ideas of liberalism and that men were created equal, the very rejection of aristocracy. So, the new ideology of the rich, what I like to call the Cult of Wealth, had to conform to these frameworks. Fortunately, for them, the founding fathers only proposed a political ideology, and the robber barons did not need to talk politics. Instead, they just needed the government to not interfere. Laissez-faire economics is what they proposed.

More importantly, they needed to establish themselves morally. Here they had help from the Puritans, who argued wealth was a sign of faith and poverty was a result of sin. Also, helped was the longstanding American view that a man controlled his own fate, including his economic one. Helping the poor could be seen as enabling and leading them to sin. Baptist Minister Russell Conwell perhaps best exemplified this view. In 1869, he started his "Acres of Diamonds" sermons, out and out equating success with godliness and poverty with sin. Later, even with its calls of noblesse oblige and arguments against inheritance, Andrew Carnegie's "Godspell of Wealth" glorified success and warned against encouraging "the slothful, the drunken, the unworthy".

But the Cult of Wealth went further. This was the 2nd Industrial Revolution, an age of science. Charles Darwin had published Origin of Species in 1859, and it had reached the shores of America to be perverted into Social Darwinism. The successful had proved them as "fitter". Success proved an inherent superior that for the good of American society needed flourish. Not only did this justify selfish arrogance, but brought forth disturbing ideas of racism.

However, there was a reason they called this the Gilded Age, as in only covered by a thin layer of gold. The idea of the self-made man is part of the origin of American, and this period did include some of its best examples. But a man unlucky in circumstances or birth, soon found those opportunities lessening. Monopolies were forming while factories were demanding more hours at lesser pay. To the man struggling to feed his family, his poverty was not the result of sin, but the greed of the rich.

The Gilded Age was as much a time of economic turmoil as it was expansion. What later would be called the Long Depression began with the Panic of 1873 and continued until the end of the 19th century.[3] Defined by cycles of booms, where a few would gain wealth and most would not, and busts, where the wealthy kept wealth and the rest lost, Laissez-faire economics was seen as widening the wealth gap and removed opportunities.

A few put down the Wealth of Nations and picked up the Communist Manifesto. Now socialism was too far for most Americans and has never been little more than a fringe movement. However, that did not stop big business and politicians from calling any deviation from Laissez-faire economics, socialism. Fear of socialism would be a commonly used political rhetoric up until, well, today.

Many Americans, however, would accept a compromise. Gaining wealth and property was fine, even encouraged, but someone did have to step in to constrain capitalism's excesses. The seeds of American Progressivism was planted.

This was the beginning of American class warfare.

But, politicians of the Gilded Age remained on the side of business. Both parties mostly argued over who could serve business better. Republicans who controlled most of the Presidency during this period promoted and took credit for the great expansion. The democrats who controlled the House were dominated by the Bourbon Democrats who were strongly pro-business through economic liberalism.

Instead, the progressive politicians were factions in each party and focused on fighting government corruption. The republican factions of Mugwumps and Half-Breeds fought the Stalwarts over government corruption in the form of the spoil system. Bourbon Democrats opposed local corruption in the form of city bosses and supported such reforms as Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act of 1883.

Instead, the fight against the robber barons birthed the first union, the Knights of Labor, later to be replaced by American Federation of Labor. Multiple strikes would happen, often met with violence from their employers, and the government always took the side of business.

All eras ends as did the Gilded Age. The three elements of the Cult of Wealth would eventually be discredited as well. Laissez-faire economics would be blamed for the Great Depressions.[4] Poverty as a result of sin would be undone by the rise of Progressivism, and Social Darwinism would become associated with a guy named Hitler.[5]

But, don't be fooled. These ideas never really died. They just got renamed and covered with new gilding. Laissez-faire economics became supply-side and trickle-down economics. Prosperity theology and cries of welfare queens practically quote the "Acre of Diamonds". And those waving their copies of Atlas Shrugged and praising "the job creators" can become Social Darwinist with a slight extension of logic.

Now, those advocating such views have focused on the positive and would surely point out how they are different. You could fairly say I am being biased. Don't worry. I will soon be showing the darker side of Progressivism. For those, who evangelize the Cult of Wealth's latest version, be warned and tread lightly. There are pieces of villainy waiting to be uncovered. Where do you think the infamous "47 percent" speech came from.

Monday, February 6, 2017

How We Got Here - Post 4

Democracy Without Slavery (Sort of)

Reconstructions creates two enduring myths


In Post 1 and 2, I discussed a lot about how American politics today are influenced by the debates of State's Right, tariffs, and slavery. Then in Post 3, I discussed how America transformed from a republic into a democracy and how the "culture wars" began. The Civil War is over, now and America is a democracy. Do I finally get to stop talking about slavery? Well sort of.

In the 3rd post, I stated that full democracy (for white males) was established in 1840 when the last state ended property requirements to vote. That's certainly how most historians describe it. However, I'm about to argue that this does not really happen until after the Civil War.

While I made a big deal about how the Electoral College gives a slight advantage to rural states (same as slave states at that time), there was another provision that gave slave states more power, the Three-Fifths Compromise. In all branches, the Constitution was written to give less populate (rural) states more representation than more populated (urban) ones. Here's what it looks like today, comparing the least populated, Wyoming, versus the most, California.

   Population Rep    Pop/Rep Ratio Elect  Pop/Elect Ratio
WY    585,501   1 585,501.00  1.26     3 195,167.00  3.66
CA 39,250,017  53 740,566.36  1.00    55 713,636.67  1.00


The House or Representatives was meant to be the most democratic, but still, a Wyoming vote counts as about 1.26 California votes. And as described before, the Electoral College is less representative. A Wyoming vote is worth 3.66 votes in California.[1]

Now let's look at what happens when we use the Three-Fifths rule.[2]

    Free Pop %Slaves Rep    Pop/Rep Ratio Elect  Pop/Elect Ratio
SC   301,302     57%   6  50,217.00  2.31     8  37,662.75  2.86
FL    15,090     44%   1  15,090.00  7.70     3   5,030.00 21.40
PA 2,906,215      0%  25 116,248.60  1.00    27 107,637.59  1.00


One vote in Florida counts as 7.7 and 21.4 votes in Pennsylvania because of their population of 44% slaves. Florida versus Pennsylvania of 1860 might be extreme, but then so is Wyoming versus California. If you need a better match consider South Carolina, not the lease populated state of the time but the one with the greatest percentage slave. While the Electoral College advantage is about the same, a South Carolinian vote was worth over double that of Pennsylvania in the House.

This advantage effectively ended with the 13th Amendment and was codified by the 14th and 15th Amendments. Removing the Three-Fifths Compromise actually increased the representation of southern states slightly (one is greater than three-fifths), but it greatly decreased the power of a white southerner. So, it's no wonder that white southerners felt like they were being oppressed.

Then again they were. The assassination of Lincoln and impeachment of Johnson redefined Reconstruction from the lenient gentle approach wished by Lincoln and Johnson to a more punitive one. On the bad side, that meant no leniency towards ex-Confederates, the removal of local governments, and occupation of the military. On the good side, that meant the protection of African Americans, including the destruction of the original KKK.

Talking about Reconstruction brings us into the same historic debate of preserving the Union versus fighting the injustice of slavery and white supremacy. But, I would like to put that off for now and describe the southern view of Reconstruction as I've come to understand it. Let me tell you about Lucas and Beauregard Duke.

They were just good men never wishing harm. Beyond what you’ve ever seen, they had trouble with the law since the day they were born. They were just good doing what they could. But, they stood against injustice and corruption like modern Robin Hoods.

Okay, enough of that. For those of you who haven’t caught on, I am talking about the 1970s TV show, The Dukes of Hazzard. The Duke brothers, under probation for moonshine-running, in the fictional Hazzard County of Georgia, continually thwarted the schemes of the corrupt county commissioner, Boss Hog. The show was really just an excuse for car stunts, a bit of southern country comedy, and daisy dukes. (Let me not forget the daisy dukes.) Now, there was nothing I see racist about this show. Boss Hog was even dressed in white. But, on top of the Dukes' car, there was a Confederate flag.

And while the Dukes of Hazzard was a show of the 1970s, that was the narrative of the Reconstruction and all the years after. The Confederate South was a defeated nation occupied by a hostile government. (Kind of true.) Weaken and vulnerable, it's people became the victims of northern exploitation and carpetbaggers. (Totally true.) Their leaders were failures and corrupt, so the only hope was the outlaw hero.

Many famous outlaws of the West, such as Jessie James, were ex-Confederate soldiers. (Often guerrilla fighters.) Disillusioned by the war, they used their skills as outlaws and became romanticized. It's become a standard American troupe. A veteran of a failed war wanders the country to become an outlaw hero. Think of Rambo, Jonah Hex, Firefly's Mal Reynolds, and even Jack Reacher.[3] So, when southerners wave the Confederate flag, they're not idolizing rich slave owners, they're idolizing the outlaw hero. It is called the Rebel Flag after all.

Of course, there's the other side of the story. The first ten amendments, Bill of Rights, were passed two years after the Constitution was ratified. So, for 74 years (1791 to 1865) only two amendments had been added. However, the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments were passed in 5 years, which is a significant amount of change in a very short time. More importantly, these amendments expanded the power of the Federal government in a way the Founding Fathers had never expected.

I already mentioned how these three amendments significantly reduced the power of 'rural' states, but they also turned on its head the idea of states themselves. The Nullification Crisis had removed the idea that a state could countermand the Federal Government. The Civil War had destroyed the idea that states have any sovereignty. These three amendments and what was to follow ended the idea that local governments protect our rights.

When established, the Founding Fathers expected that the states would protect the rights of an individual against the government, just as the Separation of Powers would. But, that's not what happened. States did not end slavery, the Federal Government did. And states were not going to protect freedmen so the Federal Government would have to. Yes, Reconstruction did open the South to exploitation, but it also expanded and protected the rights of non-whites. The Federal Government was the expander and protector of Civil Rights. The states were the oppressors.

Reconstruction ended with the Compromise of 1877 and fell short of what was hoped. The South never fully economically recovered as the more lenient Republicans wanted. While you would not describe southern states as destitute, they are still less wealthy than northern states, and Reconstruction is one of the reasons. For the more stern Republicans who wanted to bring African-Americans to full enfranchisement, once Reconstruction ended persecution soon returned, and has only recently been pushed back. (Many, including myself, feel we have to remain vigilant).

And what about the Democrats. Well, most had been participants and leaders of the Civil War, so the party did not regain political influence until Reconstruction ended. Remember how I told you white supremacy had become a part of the democrat movement with Jackson, well that became an even more significant part of the Democratic Party. Redeemer democrats soon enacted Jim Crow laws that suppressed the African-American vote. Once again the white southerner gained the oversized representation they had with the Three-Fifths rule. The Democratic party embraced the contradiction. On one hand, they remained the party of the common man, but they were also the party of white supremacists. The Republicans, on the other hand, was the Party of Lincoln and at the same time the party of big business exploiting the common man.

I've talked a lot about State's Rights and slavery so far. This is the end I was reaching for. After the Civil War, slavery ended and State's Rights became either arcane legalese or just a political talking point. What did live on, however, was the Dukes of Hazzard myth, which is how many "rural" voters see themselves. They are outlaw heroes and the victims of oppression. What big government claims as good is just taking away from the hard working to give to the corrupt and less deserving. As for racism, that's just something city slickers and hippies come up with to take advantage of real Americans.

For many "urban" voters, they see themselves as the activist heroes, the descendants of abolitionists. They understand the government does not oppress men as much as men oppress other men. Those "rural" voters just don't understand the true nature of progress.

Which party would adopt which myths switched and mangle over time, but if you listen, you will hear these stories retold today.

Thursday, January 19, 2017

How We Got Here - Post 3


The Jacksonian Era, and What I didn't Talk About

The Jacksonian Era and America's transformation from a republic to a democracy.

By now, you should have realized that the point of this post series is to show how American history formed the political arguments of today. So, far the discussion has been about State’s Rights, tariffs, and slavery. In Post 1, I showed how these issues put a slight advantage in the Constitution to the “rural” side of the persistent “urban” versus “rural” conflict in all cultures. In Post 2, I showed how the lead up to the Civil War further refined these arguments, made them regional, and linked activism with the “urban” side and Federal Government.

But, that’s over 80 years of history, and it could not have all been about State’s Rights, tariffs, and slavery. There was a reshuffling of political parties for one thing. But, more importantly, from 1807 to 1840, American evolved from a republic to our current democracy and party system. Let me address that now.

As I pointed out states decide who can vote, and up until 1840, there were states that had property requirements. The first state, to let non-property owning was New Jersey in 1807, but what really started the push towards a “common man’s” democracy[1] was the election of 1824, when John Quincy Adams defeated Andrew Jackson, despite him having a plurality[2] of votes. But, what really motivated the democratic movement was the idea that Adams had been made president by the Speaker of the House, Henry Clay, in return for being made Secretary of State, labeled as the Corrupt Bargain.

By this time, there was only one party, the Democratic-Republican Party. The other party of the 1st Party System, the Federalists, had practically ended by 1820 as a result of their unpopular opposition to the War of 1812. However, in response to the outcome of the election of 1824 and Andrew Jackon's campaign against the Corrupt Bargain[3], the Democratic-Republican Party splits. And with the election of Jackon in 1828, only the side supporting Jackon survived to become the Democratic Party[4] of today. Afterward, in opposition to the democrats, the Whig Party formed to create the American 2nd Party System.

Don't get too attached to labels and platforms here, because what the Democratic party is and its platform changes over time. So, from now on I'll refer to them as Jacksonian Democrats when talking about the specific party of this period.

Since Andrew Jackson was a southerner, the Jacksonian Democrats are often described as a southern party. However, that was more rhetoric than action. Jackson did little to promote the issues of the South (State's Rights, tariffs, and slavery) and largely just remained neutral. In fact, during the Nullification Crisis, Jackson was one of the greatest reducers of State's Rights, only to be outdone by the Civil War.

Now, help me out here because this always confounds me. What Jackson did spend a lot of time and passion on was fighting the National Bank. Granted, he lost money due to the Bank's action, and he was following existing arguments[5], but a populace issue this is not. Mostly, this appears to be an indulgence that those votings for him tolerated and gained no benefit. Resistance to the National Bank (which is now the Federal Reserve) persists today but is an issue only an obscure and passionate minority care about (with a lot of conspiracy theory thrown in).

During this period began many of our political troupes: racism, all politicians are corrupt, the common man knows more than the experts, etc. But these are the natural outgrowth of all democracies you see in history and other countries. The reasons why are worth going into, but that will have to be another post (or more likely a series of them).

We also see political themes that root in American culture: individualism, the frontier spirit, the self-made man, and self-reliance. But then again that's what we always thought American democracy should be from the beginning.

And there were events and ideas that shaped America but have no relevance today such as the Monroe Doctrine, Manifest Destiny, and two wars.

During this time many of the ideas and issues discussed in politics today were born, But rather than a central theme as I had described before, these are a melange of origin stories. In other words, these are the subplots of How We Got Here.

Perhaps where there is a bit of a trend is the way religion evolved to activism and interact with politics.

At this time, there was the threat of religious fanatics entering the country. Their beliefs were entirely incompatible with American life and if allowed, they would undermine democracy and persecute Christians. If you doubted that, there was ample evidence in the media of their terrorist acts.

I am, of course, talking about Catholics.

Ridiculous, of course, but it got a lot of politicians elected. Not until the election of John F. Kennedy did politicians stop using this form of bigotry. Remember that the KKK persecuted Catholics.

There was no causal relationship, but rooted in the same irrational fear of Catholics, was the rejection of religion being "too organized", Protestantism rose in defiance and of the Catholic Church, led to the Reformation, and partly created America. In the Protestant tradition, each man had the power and the responsibility to determine the Word of God. In other words, he had the power to leave his church or even start his own.

And so, America embraced the idea of the layman preacher. Different Protestants sects cropped up during this period (most of which disappeared) started by any man that could read a bible (or at least claimed to). These went from the adulation of pure reason, like the Unitarians, the exotic and spiritual, like Transcendentalism, and some truly radical ones with ideas of sex, marriage, diet, and even bathing that would strain our most modern sensibilities.

With this religious experimentation came activist movements lasting through to today: Sufferage, Temperance, Anti-War, Civil Disobedience and, of course, Abolition. These were not the refined debates of Jefferson and Hamilton about the role of the Federal Government. (Though even those could lead to a duel or two). These were movements of the masses with intellectual leadership, for sure, but formed more from passion and straight forward ideas of right and wrong.

But unlike political parties and church leaders, politicians don't know who they can bargain with, as is the problem today. A politician can meet with the Baptist National Convention offering help with "prayer in school" if they ease up on "gay marriage or tell the Sierra Club that he can increase regulations on coal if they let another pipeline be built. However, what guarantee was there that voters still vote for him? As prestigious as these organizations may be, there will be members not satisfied with any bargain. Members willing to form new groups and begin new opposition.

Then again politicians did not have to listen to these groups with the same way kings had to listen to the Catholic Church. From 1808[6] until the Civil War, there was little to no federal involvement on these activist issues (except for Abolition). Ultimately, activists of the Jacksonian Era had to bring their agendas to the voters, convincing them by the rightness of their cause instead of direct negotiation with politicians. They had to change American culture before they could change its politics.

In other words, this is when the first "culture wars" started, and they play out today as they did then.

Friday, December 16, 2016

How We Got Here - Post 2

In Some Ways, We are Still Fighting the Civil War

Understanding our politics today means understanding the Civil War


In the last post of How We Got Here, I described how the forming of the U.S. Constitution embedded a conflict between Northern and Southern states, or more importantly, the classic struggle between those that live an urban lifestyle versus those the live a rural lifestyle. This struggle led to the Civil War.

Before we go further, let's get the conflict right. The Northern states which I describe as urban was not that urban. In 1850, 65% of the U.S were farmers, as oppose to 2% today. That the percentage was higher in the previous 71 years is a safe assumption. Of course, the Industrial Revolution is happening during this period and primarily in the North, but it's happening slowly at this time.

As is now, the Constitution gives states the power to decide who can vote (though now affected by the 15th, 19th, 23rd, 24th, and 26th[1].) Most States viewed wealth (owning property) as a requirement, believing only those economically independent and with a financial stake in the country could vote "intelligently". Not until 1840, had all States removed this requirement. Until 1913, Senators were not elected, they were appointed.

So, during this period, America was primarily and culturally a rural nation. The Federal Government was limited and run by the rich educated elite. Politicians are still accountable to the people, but the idea of a "common man" or "populace" representative "of the people" is not even being considered until 1824[2]. What this means is that the "urban" vs "rural" dynamic we've been talking about was not, at this time, as much a conflict between elites and non-elites, but those elites that prospered from factories versus those that prospered from plantations. In other words, those that built wealth from cheap labor, including immigrants, versus those that built wealth from slaves.

Continuing along the theme of "urban" vs "rural" and the growing conflict between the North and South. These trends are known as Sectionalism, the cultural difference between the North and South as a result of the Industrial Revolution and argument over slavery that eventually led to the Civil War. Now the idea of Sectionalism has some historical controversy, because depending on how you treat it, slavery is either emphasized or deemphasized as the cause of the Civil War. I'm somewhat forced here to give my own interpretation that the growing conflict came down to tariffs, slavery, and eventually the expansion to the West. But, really slavery.

A big part of politics of this era was tariffs. As I pointed out in the last post, until 1856 tariffs accounted for 50% to 90% of the federal income. Up to the Act Prohibiting Importation of Slaves of 1807, there was some politics around the slave trade, but not on owning slaves. Much was done at the state level among the Northern States, but after 1808, federal institutions did more to protect the rights of slave owners to keep slaves such as the infamous Dred Scott Decision and Fugitive Slave Act. Until the fall of the Whig Party in 1852, the federal politics, at least, tolerated slavery and argued about tariffs.

That's not to say the slavery debate was absent. The Abolition Movement began before pen touched the pages of the Constitution and continued as the ink dried and the paper yellowed. Instead, it was more behind the scene politics. But as we discussed in the last post, southern states had created structural advantages to limit interference at the federal level. The abolitionists were more a cultural than a political threat, and worse a reminder of their hypocrisy. The rich slave owners of the South may have been politically safe, but not morally so.

Now, let me indulge in some personal observation. When people make the compromise of doing something wrong for personal gains, such as slavery, they don't just say to themselves "oh well". They form rationalizations claiming they are right and perhaps even noble. If contradicting opinions only come from outsiders or those without power, these rationalizations become stronger and can be based on even looser reasoning. In the best of cases, over time the wrongdoings eventually end, especially as the opportunities and threats to profits vanish. But, often the wrongdoings worsen as those involved become more entrenched in the beliefs that they are just. It's as if, behaving wrongly is no longer for personal gain but the need to avoid admitting you were ever wrong. And, once those wrongdoings disappear, the rationalizations can persist for generations.

This was the case for powerful southerners. An entire ideology formed justifying slavery as correct, natural, and even generous. This included a racist appeal to white supremacy, strained ideas that they were making the slaves' lives better, and even out of context quotes from the Bible. Furthermore, the North was unworthy to judge the South because of their abusive practice towards laborers and their use of tariffs to oppress the South.

The Constitution had already limited direct intervention from Northern states, so the slave owners just needed to convince the poorer southern non-slave owners. The abolitionists were painted as judgemental outsiders insulting all of the "southern way of life". The idea of "state's right" became fetishized to a point of national identity[3].

So, here we have the case I described before. Slave owners developed an elaborate rationalization for slavery, which required no real logic since only outsiders could contradict them. Given time, the Industrial Revolution and expansion West was slowly removing the need for slavery, but the South had become entrenched in their own rationalizations[4]. Making matters worse was the constant threat of slave revolts, which required ever more brutal forms of oppression. The South was a culture always under siege from outsiders and at threat from "inferiors" among them[5].

Tensions worsened as America expanded West. Eventually, the frontier became states, and as each was added, they could tip the balance towards the North or the South. Whether or not a new state prohibited slaves ("free") or not ("slave") became a serious matter. Eventually, it was all too much. Three "free" states were added in three years, Minnesota, Oregon, and Kansas. The Whig Party disbanded giving rise to the Republican Party, which did include abolitionists. And, an "abolitionist" president, Abraham Lincoln, was elected. The Civil War began.

Of course, the South lost, ending slavery and any serious arguments of state sovereignty. However, we still live with the legacy of the Civil War and its causes. The South had used the same arguments for Secession, they used to justify slavery: States Rights, an unjust Federal Government, and a threat to the "southern way of life". Perhaps, they really did believe them. The rationalizations had been used so long, they would have moved to that stage of persistence I talked about before. Certainly, the poor farmer that died on the fields of battle believed them.

I started with how the country began with an embedded conflict of "urban" versus "rural", and the lead up to the Civil War had refined them. What had been arguments between rich elites to stay rich had led to bitter war. Still, on to today, we will hear political arguments of an overpowering Federal Government, threats to the "common way of life", and appeals to resentments towards judgemental outsiders. Nothing is new about these arguments. They are standard political rhetoric, but now they have a historical context, have a siege mentality, and could all be put under the umbrella of State's Rights[6].

The other side had learned it's lessons as well. The abolitionists had won through the use of activism and the Federal Government to make the nation more just. This would echo in the movements of Suffrage, Temperance, Civil Rights, both sides of abortion, and many of the other "moral" movements that fuel our politics. What some would see as judgemental "elite and urbanite" outsiders, others would see as moral warriors who will eventually be vindicated by history.

The legacy lives on.

Sunday, November 20, 2016

How We Got Here - Post 1

The 2016 Election Starts with America's 1st Constitution

Understanding our politics today begins with knowing how the United States first formed


We will soon be inaugurating one of the most unique presidents in history. Perhaps I’m right, and we will see one of the historically worst presidencies in American history. Perhaps I’m wrong, and we will see one the best and most transformative. Or, it could be neither, defined by partisan gridlock and run of the mill legislation. I’m willing to give some time before I make more conjecture, because I’d rather be wrong than right. And, more importantly, we first have to talk about how we got here.

In July 12th 1776 (yes, I’m going back that far), the US wrote it’s 1st constitution, the Articles of Confederation. Hold on a minute. 1776? 1st Constitution? That’s just 4 days after signing the Declaration of Independence, and are you saying there was more than one constitution? Yes, I am. There were two, the Articles of Confederation ratified in 1777 and the United States Constitution written in 1787 and ratified in 1789. (The Revolutionary War ended in 1783.) So, for all the time of the Revolutionary War and 4 years after, American was a Confederacy, not a Federacy. For, us to understand where we are today, we have to remember that at the time of the founding, we were not Americans. We were Virginians, New Yorkers, Georgians, Philadelphian, etc.

However, the Confederacy was not working. We soon understood that divided, we lacked effective foreign affairs, ability to handle an inter-state economy, a strong defense against threats, and more. So, the United States Constitution was a compromise between those who wanted each state to have autonomy against those who wanted a stronger central government.. As is the nature of comprise, both sides left not fully satisfied. The argument was not truly settled until the Civil War, but that comes later. Even today, the argument still surfaces in under the idea of “State’s Rights”.

At the top of the conflict between Confederates and Federalists was, you guessed it, slavery. Now, let just start by saying that slavery is an evil institution gladly scourged (mostly[1]) from the face of the Earth. However, for us to understand the struggle of today, we cannot confused explaining the rationality of slavery as excuse or justification. We need to understand that at this time, those in governments had grown up under the rule of a monarchy where human inequality was the expected norm. More importantly, we have to understand that the leaders of the Slave States, we’re only rich and powerful man because of slavery. Not that they did not understand how slavery contradicted the founding principles of the country, However, if slavery were to be abolished, not only would the leaders of Slave States become poor and powerless, the states they were responsible for would be driven to economic collapse. For the leaders of Free States, ending slavery was a matter of morality. For the leaders of Slave States, ending slavery was an existential crisis.

And, let us not be too focused on the issues of slavery. Slavery is the top of a pyramid of issues that go back to the first walled city, rural versus urban. Walk down the streets of a big city like New York, and think about what it takes for everyone to live so close together. Imagine how you would feel about guns and pollution. How would you feel about fire regulations when a burning building can take out a city. You need rules and government to handle all those small issues that turn big when so many people live close together.

Now imagine, you live on a farm, when your nearest neighbor is at least a mile away. What others do is of little concern to you, but it takes government hours to reach you if something goes wrong. You need your gun to defend yourself, and if trouble happens your pretty much on your own. In fact, rules and regulations, especially if made for a city, can cause you to lose your farm. Those fire and fuel regulations add expenses you can ill afford, if there is a bad crop year. But for the rural dwellers matters are worse. Population and the seats of powers center in cities, not the country. A government base on city life is less likely to meet the needs of the country.

For most of human history, country folk could do little but complain. The king ruled from his castle, and you had little to say about. But, America was introducing a new form of government where the humble farmer could have as much say as a city dweller, as long as the country was not “too much democratic". That was the trick for the more agricultural Southern States. Some democracy meant no longer a king ruling from up high. Too much democracy, and those that lived in Southern States would always be subject to the whims of the more populace Northern States. So, there were compromises. The Senate, the Electoral College, and even the hypocritical and infamous three-fifths rules became compromises with the Southern States. The overall and intentional effect was to give rural voters slightly more voice than city voters.

There were many ways this struggle between rural and urban took from, and much politics that didn’t. But two ways would surface that shaped American history through to today. The first as we already mentioned was slavery, and the second was what is always fought over in politics, taxes. At the time of the founding, the main form of income for the federal government was tariffs.[2] Which tariffs you want depended on how you make your money, but in general Southern States exported and imported more than Northern States, and so would often want lower tariffs.[3] In fact, until 1913, when the 16th Amendment was passed allowing income tax, tariffs were one of the major issues that often defined politics. We’re talking about money here. That’s where the action is. And if you think, I’m exaggerating, tariffs is one of the main ways the government favor domestic products over international ones. If anti-globalism really does become one of the main goals of our current president, tariffs will again be part of the discussion.

So, there you have it. At the very beginning, the country was founded with two sides at conflict. One wanted lower taxes, less federal government, more “State’s Rights”, and attention to parochial (conservative) values. The other wanted higher taxes, more federal government, less “State’s Rights”, and more attentions to cosmopolitan (liberal) values. Is any of this sounding familiar.

And from the beginning, the system was rigged, giving a slight advantage to politicians that appealed to the rural “conservative” voter.

This is just the beginning of the story so “stay tuned”.