Showing posts with label Trump Watch. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Trump Watch. Show all posts

Thursday, November 7, 2019

The Impeachment Count - Part 2


Some Interesting Cases

Mitt Romney, Lisa Murkowski, and Susan Collins
You would think that Mitt Romney and Lisa Murkowski belong in Tier 1. They have often been vocal critics of Trump and have the most political independence from him. They also are not up for re-election. However, they aren’t compelled to vote against him either, unlike Susan Collins. So, I really don’t consider them higher than Tier 2.

Cory Gardner
This senator of Colorado is one of the most endangered ones in 2020, and who would suffer the most consequences by supporting Trump. Yet, that is not how he has been acting. A likely reason is that in this regard, the Trump team knows what they are doing. With atypical discretion, they have applied every carrot and stick to keep Gardner from defecting.

Richard Burr
Senator Burr was the Republican leader in the Senate investigation of Russian involvement in the 2016 election. That and the numbers would suggest he would at least be a voice of concern. However, so far, crickets. Either he is more partisan than he presented himself, or he is trying to be a principled juror and just not say anything.

Tim Scott
Talk about a mixed record. As the only black Republican senator, he has more than once criticized Trump’s behavior when it comes to racism. However, as representing a pro-Trump state, South Carolina, he has been more equivocal with the impeachment. Consider Tim Scott’s response to Trump’s lynching tweet.

Ron Johnson
OK, here’s one potentially for the history books. Again, by the numbers, Ron Johnson should be at least willing to go along with voting against Trump. However, there is a catch. He may be implicated in the crime, and reportedly talked to Ukraine officials while this was going on. At the least, he knew about the transgression. At worst, he participated.

Ted Cruz, Marco Rubio, and Rand Paul
What these three have in common is that they all have at some time been exceptionally critical of Trump and have, in turn, become hypocritical and sycophantic supporters of him. And, of note, they all three need Republican partisan support from their states. Rubio perhaps could change this, but at least that is the case for him now.

But more importantly, they all had, before Trump, voice ideologies that should make them his staunch critics. And they have good reason to hate him. Voting to remove Trump may not be the most politically smart move, but there would be a personal upside. Yes, it would be seen as cynical and disloyal by Republicans, but that would not be so new for them. And none are up for re-election in 2020. Heck, if they break soon enough, they could all run for President again in 2024.

I would not say turning on Trump is likely, but it’s not zero.

Mitch McConnell
Of course, Moscow Mitch is the most relevant senator in this process. The conventional wisdom is that he would want to get the trial over with as soon as possible, and that certainly is what he has been signaling. However, let’s consider him delaying the trial.

First, I don’t buy into the idea that quicker is necessarily better for either party. For all the arguments for sooner, I can think of one for later. Yes, too long is bad, but that could leave months or even a year of post-impeachment anger. In the end, it’s all really a guess. And there is a potential upside for waiting.

Consider the case of Susan Collins. Current polling says she will lose the 2020 election if she votes to exonerate. However, if she votes to remove, she is likely to get a primary challenger. And that pretty much sums up the case for any other senator where this vote is a tough choice.

But, what if the vote were after March next year when it would be too late for a primary challenger to file. Note that the bigger threat of voting against Trump is in the primary, not the general election. So, if the vote was late enough Collins could vote as she needed with no primary threat. And I expect other senators have a similar case.

More so, what if Moscow Mitch waited until after the election. If Trump has lost, then the vote will have limited consequences. If Trump won, the Senate could vote to remove him if they wished. Then they have the best of both worlds. With a full two years until the election, there would be a reduced backlash from Trump supporters, and the new President would be the much more acceptable Pence.

Yeah, I don’t see these scenarios as likely. But, again, not impossible.

Tuesday, November 5, 2019

The Impeachment Count - Part 1


The Tracking Republican Senators


I’m out of time.

I’ve owed you a track of Congress vs the President for over a year now, so with impeachment looming here, it is. A new button, Impeachment Count.

So, first, some of the ground rules.

This time we're counting for removal from office and just removal from office.
Before, I was seeing if Congress would keep the President from being “threatening”. That’s no longer a question since 2018. The House will block him. The Senate will block the House. Trump will try to be a dictator but will fail due to his own incompetence.

There is also no doubt as to will he be impeached. He will. The moment the Speaker announced the inquiry, impeachment was certain. She would not have done it if there were not the votes. And not voting now would be political malpractice. So, the only question is when.

Therefore, the only question left is whether there are enough, if any, Republican senators that would remove the President from office.

However, Speaker Pelosi’s goal is not removal.
The Speaker has to delicately time the vote. She has to give enough time that all the evidence that can be found is found, but not too long as so the inquiry can be made to look only political. Also, until the Impeachment vote happens, she (and by extension the Democrats) are in control. After that, Moscow Mitch is. Reason enough for her to keep the inquiry going as long as she can.

Given that she still is unlikely to get enough Republicans to vote for removal by that time. However, what she can do is make a vote against removal look so craven, she ensures control of the House, damages Trump’s re-election, and threatens Republican control of the Senate.

That’s the real battle here.

It’s 1, 4, 20, or 27
Remove of a president requires 67 senatorial votes. That means 20 Republicans in addition to the 47 Democrats. However, there is one vote that matters more than the others, Majority Leader Mitch McConnel.

What Moscow Mitch could do is unclear, but he could and is capable of is using whatever procedural trick is available. (Remember Merit Garland?) By his statement, the senate is constitutionally required to have a trial and a vote. However, "how long you're on [the trial] is a whole different matter." In other words, he could choose to have the vote 1 hour after the impeachment, leaving no time for any evidence being brought to the public. Or, he could delay the vote until after the election. My understanding is that it would have to happen while the current Senate is in power, but that would still leave about 3 months after we know who the next president is.

My usual measure as to if Moscow Mitch turns against Trump is that over half of the Republican senators want it. That number is 27.

However, removal is not the only adverse outcome for Republicans and the President. A clearly craven vote by senators would be electorally dangerous, especially if it looks bipartisan. That could mean as little as 4 Republicans, making the vote a straight majority, would cause harm.

Tiers of Desperation
Again, I must remind you how bad it would be for a Republican senator to vote for removal. At the very least, they will be viewed as disloyal, and their voters will be unmotivated. Effectively, all power would be ceded to the Democrats at the next election.

More likely, after a time, those senators will be the targets of political operatives and pundits who still believe the President should have been protected. Under the best scenarios, that would be over half of registered Republicans. And if the Trump remains, he’s made clear that will use all power and influence he has to attack those that voted against him, even at risk of Republican control of the Senate.

Before you judge them, honestly, ask yourself. What would you be willing to do if it risked your job? Not only your career but everything you worked for because that is what likely will happen. Democrats will gain all the power, pick the judges, increase the size of government, take away tax cuts to the rich, and add regulations.

Most would not show “political courage” under those conditions, any form of rationalization would be welcome, and every instinct would be to duck your head and hope it all just goes away.

Times would have to be desperate indeed. Meaning, only expect senators to vote for removal if:
  • Their voters would punish them.
  • They are safe and want to.
So who are they:

Tier 1 – Those who will vote against Trump regardless.
These would be senators who have the conviction that the President should be removed and either will suffer no consequence or would be punished for supporting Trump. They are willing to vote even if Trump is not removed.

Tier 2 – Those who will lead the charge.
These are the senators who need to know that he will be removed if they vote against him but are willing to tell others this. There needs there to be 20, but they are the first to say they are part of the 20.

Tier 3 – Those that say “count me in.”
These are the senators who will happily vote to remove Trump, but only if it will succeed and won’t take the lead.

Tier 4 – The wildcards
These are the senators who have a mixed record. There are good reasons for them to oppose the President, and at least one time they have. However, they have also shown unusual support for him at others. In some cases, they reached the point of being political opportunists.

Where to find them
So how do we look for these mysterious senators?

Retiring and when is their re-election.
First, I would look at retiring senators, of which there are currently four. These have the best option of “voting their conscious” and can think more about how their acts will be viewed in history. Also, and sadly, most are retiring due to health concerns, so even factors that I mentioned in Speaker Ryan’s retirement are not an issue.

Though, oddly, only one, Lamar, has voice anything negative towards Trump’s behavior. The others, in fact, have criticized the inquiry. So, those three could be “true believers” or so partisan to still excuse these acts. However, at the very least, I have to believe any senator retiring would vote for removal if enough other senators do.

Then, we can look at those up for re-election in 2024. A lot can happen in 4 years, and that is plenty of time to survive past any political harm a vote against their party would do. However, that group is small, 6, and since they were elected when Trump had the most influence, 2018, only one, Mitt Romney, has spoken against the President. Others, such as Ted Cruz and Rick Scott, have been practically sycophantic towards Trump.

Then, there is 2022. 2 years is not as good as 4 years, but that does give a little time. Not enough to free them of political worry, but it does help.

And, of course, those up in 2020 are going to be the ones most driven by electoral concerns.

Their States
As would be no surprise, the state a senator represents has a lot to do with how they vote. In fact, senators should vote for who they represent. Thus, we look at whether a state is anti-trump, pro-trump, safe, or “swingy”.

Note that the support of a state is not as simple as whether it is blue, red, or purple. What matters is the senator’s relationship with his state. So, despite Utah being a very red state, their view of Trump is at best look warm and have better regard for Mitt Romney, making it a safe state.

Also, there are two ways a state can be purple. The populace could have a mix of left and right views or, more likely, they could have staunch, but equal, areas of red and blue. In the first case, the state is more likely to waiver in support of Trump, if they have not done so already. However, in the second case, that can make it harder for the senator to oppose Trump because he more desperately needs to turn out those red areas.

What I would look at first is whether Trump won that state in 2016. If they did not want him, then it’s unlikely they changed their minds. As you might expect, there are only 2 states with Republican senators: Colorado and Maine. After that, I would look at which states have a Democratic and Republican senator as it’s a strong indication of a bipartisan populace. And finally, there is the state’s approval/disapproval rating of Trump. (Unfortunately, state by state polls on the impeachment question are barely available and problematic.)

The more complicated case is Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. Trump won both of those (starting our national nightmare), but they are still blue states with low approvals of him. Have they now rejected Trump, or could their Republican senators rely on pro-Trump areas?

What they’re saying.
Of course, there is what the senators are actually saying about impeachment. Short answer. Not much.

Even Mitt Romney, the most vocal critic, has not given more than “it would be bad if”. Then again, what should they say? It would be improper for them, even Democratic senators, to prejudice themselves before there is a trial.

That doesn’t stop us from “reading the tea leaves”, however.

So, how are we doing?
Not good. As of now, I only have 16 in the first 3 tiers, which means we need some wild cards to reach the 20. But, hey, I’ve been saying for a while not that impeachment in the first term was not going to happen and would if there was a second. I’d like to be wrong, but it still doesn’t look like it.

What could change?

The Polls Of Course

Given that reelection is what most senators are worried about, approval on removal and/or Trump could shift them. However, that’s problematic because it’s not the national polls that matter. It’s the state polls, and the states almost all of these senators represent are the least likely to shift.

The Growth of Independents
There is a way the polls are misleading. As I pointed out in Why Democrats Feel They’re Always Losing, determining what party a person belongs to is not straightforward. Depending on how the question is asked, the pollster could be talking to an “independent” that just yesterday was a Republican. In other words, if a Republican begins to believe Trump should be removed, then they are probably considering no longer being a Republican.

If we see the overall numbers growing towards impeachment but not among Republicans, then that is what is going on. 

Retirements
The easiest way for a senator to avoid a horrid election and still vote for removal is just not run. So, any senators announcing retirement now immediately becomes a candidate. I would also keep watch on those senators already retiring but still supporting the President.

Trump Himself
Given who we are talking about, the person most pushing senators to remove him is him. Right now, senators are trying more subtle messages: the process is wrong, it’s bad but not illegal, it’s illegal but no worth removal, etc. However, all those say Trump did something wrong, and he’ll have none of that. Anything short of out and out exoneration is viewed by him as disloyal.

And that’s to start. Trump is capable of doing more impeachable acts or just stupid, dangerous ones, like retreating from Syria. And then there is the economy. I know you want to call the senators cowardly rats, so guess what rats do on sinking ships.

Saturday, May 20, 2017

How Much Does Trump Firing ComeyThreaten Us? - Part 3

For the Good of the Country, Make Trump a 1 Term President 

Only by putting the House under democratic control can we keep the President Trump from threatening our democracy.
Republican Lack of Will and Wishful Thinking
has Endangered Us

In part 1 and part 2, I warned that the likelihood for a Threatening Presidency though Medium is dangerously close to High.
  • Attempt: High 
  • Competence: Medium
  • No Check: High -> Medium
Having already explained my ranks for Attempt and Competence, I will now explain No Check.

If you read the two previous posts, I had the No Check rank at High, but understandably, I’ve moved it back to Medium because Special Counsel Mueller was appointed. I am tentatively optimistic that it keeps this current threat contained. However, I am not overly so that we are safe from the next threat.

The Comey firing was a threat to our democratic progress. The only argument was whether the damage went beyond what the last two presidents have done. Thankfully, that question is irrelevant. We were alerted to it by Trump’s incompetence. And, he was checked by an institution, the justice system. Future presidents cannot hide their wrongdoing by firing their investigator.

So now, some parsing. I am watching for a Disaster Presidency and a Threat Presidency separately. They are certainly related, but as I pointed out in part 2, a potential disaster only protects us against certain kinds of threat. Wrongdoing found by the Special Counsel is a disaster that congress may act on, but future obstruction is the kind of threat they might ignore. There is a need to watch for what I described in part 2 as the Accidental Dictator.

What is concerning is that he was only stopped by the courage (or survival instinct) of a single individual, Deputy Attorney General Rubenstein. Our democracy protected by only the right person in the right place is not comforting. There may not be such an individual next time. So, far we have only been protected by leaks and the court (help by state governments). The check designated by the Constitution, Congress, has not come to our rescue, nor do I believe it will. How can I say that? History.

Fundamental to Trump becoming president is the Republican Party’s lack of will to stop him. Despite him stating he had no allegiance to their party, they let him run in their primary. Though constantly contradicting principles with which they have righteously judge the rest of us, they elected him as their nominee. Though well within their own rules and historical precedent, no one challenged him during the convention and let him have the nomination. Constantly prominent congressman voice objections to his behavior, then almost immediately endorsed him.

I understand why. They wanted to keep their jobs. Doing any of what I listed would have created a backlash endangering their re-election, even in the safest state/district. That has not changed. Of three presidents to be “impeached”[1] (Andrew Johnson, Richard Nixon, and Bill Clinton), they were all done when the opposite party controlled the Congress, and many would agree that at least one of these “impeachment” was only politically motivated. We just argue about which one.

Simple fact, there is little chance President Trump will be removed from office.

But then, I am not asking him to be impeached. I’m asking the Congress to take lesser steps. How about a declaration that if he fires the next FBI director, congress will consider putative action? Congress could censure the president (though that would do little). At the very least, stop attacking one of the few checks that has been working, leaks.

Instead, they have cravenly done none of this. In their initial response to Comey’s firing, just a quarter of senators have said anything against Trump and then only in the most parsed and vague language. As I pointed out in part 2, they only increased the rhetoric when he should dangerous incompetence. Congress has been like the parents that let their kid kick strangers in the shine and says, “He’s such a handful. What can you do?”.

Again, I understand. Republican voters demand a huge price for disloyalty, and integrity gives little electoral reward. I said I understand. I don’t condone.

That the President endangers democracy is not enough. It’s also not enough that he endangers their re-election. They must be certain, with no possibility of doubt and, maybe not even then, they may embrace wishful thinking like we heard before. (He’ll change. He’ll have good people around him, etc.) Until Trump is so unpopular that they see no hope of being re-elected, we cannot expect the Congress to be a check on the President.

And there, the situation is sadder. Conservative media has fully embraced the idea that the Russian Investigation is only politics and “fake news”. There is no surprise that his aggregate approval is still above 38%[2]. I can’t see the House become a real check until those approvals get into the low 30%, and still, it will be the least they can get away with. Only 2 senators need to worry about non-republican votes in 2018. I’m not certain there is a number low enough to move the Senate.

Considering this, I have a recently updated to the Congress Count:
  • 52/238 is the Senate/House Success Count
  • 64//217 is the Senate/House Disaster Count
  • 16/23 is the Senate/House Resistance Count
As you would expect, the Disaster Count did go up but not by enough. (Que outrage.) Looking at senators that have spoken out, I can only comfortably add one new senator, Bob Corker. Representatives have been silent. (Que more outrage.) So, I looked at those who voted against the AHCA. This does put us just short of the 67/218[3] we need, and you would think that would calm me some. However, there was I reason I did not make the Disaster Count the same as the Threatening Rank. The Disaster Count measures whether Congress will react to President Trump after the disaster happens. That’s reactive. What we are asking is whether they will proactively stop him. It’s the difference between taking the car keys away after the crash or taking them before the drunk driver gets into the car. For that, it must start with two people, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and House Speaker Paul Ryan.

Therefore, I added a new count, the Resistance Count.[4] This is the Disaster Count minus any democrats. The theory is that to push McConnell and Ryan, they first must worry about losing their majority seat. Over fifty present of their party must want it. By that measure, 16/23, means we must rely on their conscience to act. (Que shiver.)

Now, the democrats winning the House in 2018 has become critical to protecting our democracy. History and convention say they will, but we are far from a guarantee. The senate is almost assuredly to remain in control of republicans. Still, the House would be enough to continue investigations that neither the President nor republicans can stop. However, do not count on impeachment. The House has the power to call impeachment, but if it does not pass the Senate, Trump would more likely be helped as Clinton was. Instead, a more realistic goal is to win the House, keep him in check, and make sure the American people understand the full details of his unfitness. Then, we can end this nightmare in 2020.

Wednesday, May 17, 2017

How Much Does Trump Firing ComeyThreaten Us? - Part 2

Rise of the Accidental Dictator

The be hope against a Trump destroying democracy is his incompetence. But is that enough.


WARNING: Do not read this while drinking. It will make you sad and drink more. A lot more.

In part 1, I warned that the likelihood for a Threatening Presidency is still Medium but on its way to High
  • Attempt: High 
  • Competence: Medium 
  • No Check: High 
Having already explained the increase in Attempt, I will now cover Competence

The good news is that these past days does not indicate he has gained competence. The true potential dictator would have waited, coordinated a better message, and had someone to take Comey's place. He also never would have admitted to the real reason during an interview, and if he had tried to interfere before the firing, would have done so in less suggestive ways.

But, he didn't. That what keeps his Competence at Medium, and these past days a little entertaining.

However, he hasn't (yet) shown an increased incompetence. Hard to believe, but if we look overall, he is learning some (like don’t let Bannon write an executive order), but the bigger progress is with his staff. More accurately, the incompetent personnel is being replaced. But, if he can continue to demand and get personal loyalty, eventually enough competence will surround him to be dangerous. Then again, he could be plagued by constant turnover and only to get mediocre replacements. (I certainly would not want to work for him after this week.)

But the main reason I’m keeping him at medium is that if he can keep his Delusional above 35%, he does not have to be that competent to hurt us. An important distinction is that the Competence Rank is not a judgment of overall competence. It is whether he can follow through with his attempt. He is far from competent enough to execute a coup or autocratic agenda. What he is competent enough to, however, is become what I call the Accidental Dictator. The firing of Comey is a perfect example. Just by disregarding our political norms he has potentially harmed our ability to hold future presidents accountable. One can easily see a scenario where external events combined with his autocratic response bring back atrocities of the past (“red scare”, Operation Wetback, Internment Camps, Jim Crow law, etc).

To be an Accidental Dictator, you don’t need to be that competent.

Where overall competency makes a difference for the Accidental Dictator is when it directly harms his followers and supporters. We can see this when he leaked classified data to the Russians. That created more negative reaction than firing Comey did. It could be just the “last straw”, but compared to firing Comey, the leak was legal and not malevolent. However, the Comey firing was a threat to democracy with no tangible harm (for us). The leak to Russia was a plain-out threat that someone could die over.

Part of what makes a Delusional so delusional is that politics does not "feel real”. It feels like cheering or booing at a football game, or better yet the WWF. But, when a President’s actions harm national security or the economy that is real and can pierce the delusion. Again, this is why a Disaster Presidency can’t be a Threatening Presidency. At the time of writing this, President Trump’s aggregate approval rating, on FiveThirtyEight and RealClearPoltics, are at their worse since he became president. However, they are still higher than President Clinton’s was around this time. If they hit below 35%, then even Delusionals are leaving him. Also, a recent drop in the stock market is being attributed to Trump’s incompetence, which takes money away from the financial supporters of republicans. These are the kind of trends that spur politicians to action.

But don’t relax just yet. Once President Trump’s incompetence becomes tangible (low polls, etc.), he improves or at least stops making it worse. Given time, republicans seem quite happy to forget his last misadventure. Unfortunately, one-third of the country is willing to risk harm to the rest of us as long as they remain untouched. That makes me sad. If you're sad as well, again I warned you. I need a drink.

---------------------------------------------------

Just as I was writing the last line, former FBI Director Robert Mueller was appointed Special Counsel by Deputy Attorney General Rosenstein. With only minutes after the announcement, no one can say what will happen next. (Not that will it stop us from trying.) This is a good outcome, if for no other reason than it's a return to the president being accountable to the law.

But considering what I just wrote, I'd like to engage in a little self-promotional conspiracy theory. The Special Counsel does offer one potential benefit to republicans. The Special Counsel will probably say little until all facts are known, which could be years from now. Note that this was done on the day the stock market had a big loss, and when congressmen became legitimately worried of new damning evidence (the Comey memos). Not to mention, the President is about to leave the country.

Here's what to watch for. Are republican congressmen happy or angry about this? Again, this is all self-promotional conspiracy theory.

Sunday, May 14, 2017

How Much Does Trump Firing Comey Threaten Us? - Part 1

How Firing Comey Makes the Trump Presidency More Threatening 

A President firing the FBI Director is a potential threat to democracy

WARNING: Do not read before going to bed. You will lose sleep over this.

So here I am. Behind on my posts. Figure I need to write one about the AHCA, and just as I hit publish… He did again. Something so unprecedented and disturbing that I must update the Trump Watch. I am of course talking about the FBI Director being fired while the FBI is investigating Russian influence into the Trump campaign.

The likelihood of a Threatening Presidency is still Medium but on its way to High
  • Attempt: Medium -> High
  • Competence: Medium
  • No Check: Medium -> High
As we should remember, ‘Attempt’ is how likely I feel Trump is to act in a way that harms democracy. ‘Competence’ is his and his administration ability to succeed. And ‘No Check’ is how likely I think Congress will let him do it. Right now these three ranks translate to me saying he is highly likely to try (Attempt), Congress is highly like to let him (No Check), and his lack of Competence is the best chance to prevent it. For now, I’ll explain why the Attempt rank has increased. In a later post, I will go into the other two ranks.

That I had increased the Attempt rank to High probably does not surprise you. You’re probably wondering why I did not go to Very High since he arguably is attempting right now. So, forgive me, but I’m about to parse words.

Before Trump being elected I asked if he was a “threat to democracy”, which if anything, he is less of a threat. As I pointed out in The First Step of Many, to reach the final steps of an existential threat, he needs the support of the military or a paramilitary. Firing Comey looks like this will alienate the FBI and does not help him to organize his own paramilitary. To change that, he would have to appoint a fanatical FBI Director and purge resistant FBI agents, which we have become more alert to (hopefully)

However, we aren’t asking if he is a “threat to democracy” anymore, we are asking if he is ““threat to democratic progress””. Does firing Comey, risk rolling back our democratic progress. Yes. Yes, it does. That should be obvious. What is not obvious is whether it does more than previous presidents. So, let’s look at some comparable actions in the past two presidencies.
  1. Rolled back Civil Rights (W. Bush through the Roberts Court)
  2. Mass dismissal of U.S. Attorneys (W. Bush)
  3. Increased surveillance (W. Bush, Obama)
  4. Questionable use of Signing Statements (W. Bush)
  5. Assassinated a U.S. Citizen (Obama)[1]
This list is incomplete and you may object to items that are included. Also, W. Bush and Obama progressed our democracy. That's not the point. This is an exercise to keep President Trump actions in perspective.

What is in common with the firing of Comey is that they all have little proven[2] effect on us. They also share the concern that each erodes a check on presidential power. However, in that sense, President Trump has not only attempted but succeeded. He has already removed the norm of a presidential candidate showing his tax returns and not having business ties while serving as president. Regardless of what would be found, if the Russian Investigation is not completed, we may never be able to investigate a future presidents’ wrong doings.

Here is the troubling difference. All that I listed for W. Bush and Obama was for, what they viewed, the good of the country. There was no opportunity for gain. Trump fired Comey only for Trump. Only a Trump Delusional would not see this. More worrisome is that this fits an autocratic pattern that I can no longer ignore.

I've been hesitant to base my reasoning on Trump's personality, but he has consistently dealt with confrontation the same way that I feel more confident now. The pattern seems to at first threaten or bully, and if that does not work, charm. I won't go as far as to say that he has an authoritarian personality. A narcissist can also act authoritarian. However, I have enough experience in a hierarchical organization to say that he behaves in an authoritarian way.[3]

The problem is that the U.S. is not an authoritarian country. We have checks and balances, and so the President must expect to be checked. More importantly, he must be checked sometimes by those that work for him, like an FBI Director. An authoritarian politician will eventually adapt to this. As well can an authoritarian CEO. Even high-ranking military officers do. But a, born rich, 70-year old who’s only run a family business never needs to adapt. He only needs to threaten, bully, or charm.

At this point, I no longer ask if Donald Trump will try to threaten democratic progress. I only ask when. He will keep running into situations he cannot solve by threatening, bullying, or charming, and then will take extreme acts in conflict without democratic norm. Each time he succeeds, he gains the ability to do worse and worse. Eventually, that will reach beyond the processes of government to the rest of us being harmed.

If that make you unable to sleep, remember that I did warn you.

Tuesday, April 11, 2017

The First Step of Many

Update to the Threatening Presidency Watch

As I’m sure you heard, as of five days from writing this, the U.S. Navy launched and air strike against a Syrian airfield in response to Assad’s latest chemical attack. Talking politically about such a subject is in poor taste too soon after such an event. That has not stopped partisan media, however, which I feel is too soon. Unfortunately, I must be a hypocrite on that sentiment. My defense is that there are dangers that can sneak by while we adhere to the demands of empathy and patriotism. For me, that means I need to update the Trump Watch for a Threatening Presidency.

The rank has moved from Low to Medium:
  • Attempt: Medium 
  • Competence: Low -> Medium 
  • No Check: High -> Medium 
Before I go further, let me clearly say that I tentatively support the President's actions in Syria. As of now, the attack was appropriate and well executed. I say 'tentatively' because we cannot know the full wisdom of such actions until we see the results and follow-up over time.

Having said that, let me now get into why it raises the risk of a Threatening Presidency. The simple answer is that it was a well-executed attack and military competence is a precursor to exactly the kind of increased power political leaders use to harm their own people. This is why I moved the Competence rating from Low to Medium. As I pointed out before, the dilemma of wanting competent leadership over the next 4 to 8 years is that it makes a Threatening Presidency possible. Military competence is the greatest threat because the President can achieve it unilaterally and the support of the military is a requirement for the most dangerous threats, such as a government overthrow or civil war.

Ok, that sounded pretty disturbing, but don't panic (yet). There are many many steps before we get to that point. And that is the reason for me doing this kind of Trump Watch so we can keep a balanced assessment without devolving into a panic. Furthermore, at the same time, the failure AHCA, republican senators’ current behavior in the Russian investigation, and the recusal of Rep. Nunes are all indications that the let me lower the No Check rank from High to Medium.

To clarify, let me talk about the Syrian strike in terms of good and bad news.

The Good News First

  1. The Syrian strike was a conventional action. Reports are that President Trump relied on the advice of serious generals and not his inexperienced and ideologue advisors. The initial indication is that, at least, in military action, he will behave conventionally, which reduces chances of disaster and him using the military to promote a Threatening Presidency.
  2. The worst of his supporters were put to the sideline. Reports are that Bannon influenced has decreased, and the attack is contrary to the political philosophy Bannon has been advocating. Lately, there have been some signals that Bannon's issues have been resolved, so it's too soon to tell. However, if Bannon continues to be distanced from the President, I would consider lowering the Attempt rank.
  3. This is more evidence that the President "has a heart". I have no doubt that he is capable of viciousness, but remember that people are always more complicated than that. I've noticed for some time that he has not yet countered DACA. There are rumors and threats, but his hesitation, to me at least, suggests that when the President is confronted, in a personal way, with the harm he can do, he is drawn to decency. His response to the Syrian chemical attack is more evidence of this, and, hopefully, decency could stay his head from other actions. 

Now the Bad News

  1. This could escalate. I won't get into all the ways the Syrian attack could make the situation worse. There's plenty of other articles detailing this. For our purposes, if our military engagement increases, this creates opportunities for the President to claim more power.
  2. The President could learn a bad lesson. There's a good chance the President's approval will go up. Historically, it will not last long, and I doubt it will go beyond the high forties. However, there's about 20% of the population looking for any reason to feel better about the President. Given past behavior, this could lead the President to believe that any kind of military intervention helps him. Where that goes gets scary.
  3. This is a return to the Imperial Presidency. Since the 1930s, the presidency has increased in power, especially in the use of military power. Now, this is something, only a portion of political junkies care about, and all presidents have added to this concern, including President Obama. But President H.W. Bush did make a step back by asking for congressional approval to enter the Gulf War. No President has conceded they must get approval, even though the Constitution clearly states so. However, presidents have made either a pretense of constitutionality, before issuing the attack, or directly asked for congressional approval. That President Trump did this unilaterally puts the Imperial Presidency back on track. Normally this would be just academic, but the concern was that if we continued to let the Presidency get unchecked power, one day we would get a president that truly abuses them. Well... 
There is a temptation to say that the attack on Syria was politically motivated. From my research, thus far, I have not found a case where a past president has use military action only to promote him politically. However, there are cases where they have done so to become president. (We now know that Nixon sabotaged Vietnam War peace talks to improve his chances of being elected.) With any other president, I would not have these concerns. Once assuming the office, the awesome responsibility of military action made them act under conventional norms. But, what we all agree on is that President Trump is unconventional.

Sunday, March 12, 2017

The Presidential Elevator Pitch

What Does a Successful Presidency Mean

Let’s talk more about the Successful Presidency and let me extend on that definition because I need to. My previous definitions have been too vague. As I have already pointed out. I can only measure if President Trump is perceived as successful. By that standard, many would not call Obama' presidency successful (about 40%). I'm also sure that if Trump's presidency is not a disaster, many (probably the same 40%) will declare him the greatest president ever. (He certainly will.[1])

What I'm really thinking of is how the President's party will treat him after his term is over. A party will always refer to the last president they view as successful enough to associate with. Republicans usually use Reagan because they did not want to be associated with the 2 presidents after him. President H.W. Bush had only been elected one term and President W. Bush had.... well you know.

For democrats, they could go back to President Clinton because the economy had been so good. Before that, they usually went back to President Kennedy.

Obviously, that changes over time. President W. Bush is looking a lot better compared to the current President, and President Clinton is looking worse due to revisiting it in the Hillary Clinton's campaign. But, at some point, we start talking about how historians will think and not what politicians think.

Usually, this means that when you think of a president, mostly good achievements come to mind. Here's what I mean:

Reagan (Success)

  • What 1st Comes to Mind: defeated the Soviet Union, the "Reagan Revolution", Tax Reform
  • What 2nd Come to Mind: Iran-Contra Scandal, 1983 Beirut barracks bombings

H.W. Bush (Failure)

  • What 1st Comes to Mind: a bad economy, not re-elected, Savings and Loans Scandal
  • What 2nd Come to Mind: 1s Iraq War, Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

Clinton (Mixed)

  • What 1st Comes to Mind: a good economy and tech boom, sex scandals, NAFTA
  • What 2nd Come to Mind: Bosnian War, checks against Saddam Hussein's aggression, Welfare Reform balanced budgets, tax increases

W. Bush (Disaster)

  • What 1st Comes to Mind: 2nd Iraq War, Financial Crisis, 9/11
  • What 2nd Come to Mind: Medicare Drug Act, aid to Africa

Obama (Success for now)

  • What 1st Comes to Mind: ACA (Obamacare), killed Osama Bin Laden, kept us out of a depression
  • What 2nd Comes to Mind: failure to close Guantanamo Bay, BP Oil Spill, VHA scandal
  • To Be Determined: ISIS

I'm sure you would come up with a different list. Many do remember the 1st Iraq War and don't even know there was a Savings and Loans scandal when thinking of H. W. Bush. Also, some are subjective. The "Reagan Revolution" is the greatest thing ever to a conservative and a horror to progressives. Don't even get me started on deficit spending. But, hopefully, you see the point. After writing down your own list (without falling to the Great Delusion of Politics), you will see one president harder to sell, then others.

But, who does the selling? Why other members of the party hoping to be elected, and that's what the Success Count should measure. How much other politicians think they can sell this president. In other words, the Presidential Elevator Pitch. Thus. it’s not an idle exercise. If other politicians believe they will not be able to sell him in the future, they are encouraged to distance themselves from him and no longer defend him. That will harm his legacy and mean the difference between success and failure.

Now look. Whatever happens, his Delusionals will insist he was great and any failure was just the system being rigged. The question is this. Will there be enough fans, after he is no longer president, for politicians to invoke his name or pretend he was never president?[2]

In this way, the Presidential Elevator Pitch can become a shorthand for the Success Count. Think of three outcomes that a non-partisan would be most likely to remember. Don’t forget to avoid the Great Delusion of Politics. Here would be my list so far:
  1. Travel Ban
  2. Russia
  3. Twitter
Unless you are a Delusional that list looks bad. Perhaps, there will be enough fervent support to continue to pressure republican politicians, but that tends to hurt as much as it helps.[3] Without a better list, the Trump Presidency might at best be remembered as a good reality TV show.

Sunday, March 5, 2017

What Counting Teaches Us

Projections of the Latest Congress Count

Here are my latest Success and Disaster Count
52/237 is the Senate/House Success Count
61/206 is the Senate/House Disaster Count
First, off the bat, you should notice that I now have House Counts which you can look at in the Congress Count link. I’ll get into those in a bit.

Second, you should now realize there is nothing Trumpy about these numbers. I could go through the same exercise with any President. (It’s just this guy made us feel we needed to.) Furthermore, these numbers (right now) are more a factor of partisanship. I would not be surprised if I got similar numbers for President Obama.

In general, what they say is that President Trump is safe from any opposition, but he will not be able to do much except basic President stuff. How can that change?

In order to increase the Success Count to 60, 8 democratic senators have to shift. That would not take a lot. 10 are up for re-election in either republican or swing states. However, as long as protests are high and Trump's approval is bellow 50%, these senators have to worry about being primaried.

If the 538 Trump Democratic Average drops bellow -5, I would consider adding the 5 senators in republican states. I've marked these 5 with '?' as they will be the first to go. If his approval goes above 50%, I would add the other 4 in swing states.

In order to get the Disaster Count to 67, 6 republican senators and 12 representatives have to shift. The first to look for is Dean Heller, but I would not give much hope. Despite him representing a swing state, his history and current voting do not support independence. After that, there are no more senators from swing states to add.

If President Trump's approval, however, starts to drop bellow 40%, I would look for more signs of independence. I've marked those where Trump won the least with '?'. The bad news is that I had to go as high as him winning by +15% to reach 6 (without including Dean Heller). The good news is that one of the +15% is Lindsey Graham. (I also can't believe one of the '?' is Ted Cruz. Good God, I'm looking for Ted Cruz to save us.)

Note, that Rand Paul comes from a +30% state so any senator could be added. However, as time goes forward I will also have to raise my criteria for 'independence' which would more likely shift the counts lower. I call this 'honing'.[1]

The House is more shifty (pun intended). As you know, majorities rule in the House. (Yeah, I made another pun.) So, If Paul Ryan stands with Trump and holds the House together, the House will stand as well. (And another one. Wait. Just one more.) You could say that with the support of all three branches, the President is tri-trump-phant. (OK. I'll stop now.)

Therefore, over the next 2 years, we only need to know what makes the House Disaster Count go up. Well, first Paul Ryan has to want it. After that, finding the additional 12 representatives is easy. 16 have already voted at least once against him, and an additional 18 are in states that voted against Trump. Though, these 18 have not yet voted against them, which is why I've only marked them with a '?'. 5 seats are also vacant and up for special elections this year. Again, watch out for 'honing'

Now, how does this play out over the next 8 years? (Yeah, I said 8. Don't bury your head just yet.)

Before 2018

As of now, congress is at a standstill. (What else is new.) The President can do much in the areas of foreign policy and immigration without congress. However, without congress, he will lack some tools.[2]

The Success Count is enough to provide basic funding, but he will not be able to modify departments, build the Wall, impose or lessen sanctions, pass new treaties, and so.

What he needs is to get non-trumpies on his side, enough that at least eight democratic senators will support him.

In determining President Trump's future, congress's biggest role is to keep him out of real trouble (investigations, impeachment, etc.). What tends to be missed is that the trumpies love him, not his staff. The President could find his staff picked away by scandal and leaving him effectively neutered.

And forget about new trade treaty, only trade agreements he can negotiate without congress.

2018

Obviously, the midterm election will change the numbers. The biggest change could be in the House, History is against the President, especially with an approval rating in the 40s. As stands, there is a good chance democrats could control the House. There, however, is a lot of volatility here, so that is far from certain.

However, the likely result is that the republicans keep the Senate, even if the President popularity goes lower. There are just too many democrats up for re-election and too few republicans. The Senate Success Count could raise to 60, but it's unlikely even if the political environment improves.

After 2018

Here we have two realistic scenarios: either the congressional makeup stays the same or democrats take control of the House. In the first scenario, we have the same dynamic as today. In the second, the Congress is still at a standstill, but democrats can run investigations unhindered. That could begin the end for President Trump.

2020

Obviously, if he loses, the story's done. He's at best viewed only as a footnote in history and at worse a public failure. So, let's assume he wins. (Take a deep breath. We're just talking a hypothetical here.)

Predicting the Senate elections is surprisingly easy. The opposite is true of 2018. There are 2 republicans to 1 democrat up for re-election so republicans will lose seats. The Senate will again not have enough of a majority on either side to do much. The only question is whether enough seats were gained in 2018 to offset the loss in 2020.

No change over the next 4 years is an outrageous assumption. But this is a projection, not a prediction, That's how a projection works and why it is less accurate the further you project.

For the House, there are two possibilities. Either democrat resistance is holding strong at which point the House falls incrementally to democrat control, or the House gets locked into a cycle where it switches between parties.

Before 2022

Either we have the same as before 2018 or 2020 depending on whether republicans control both the Senate and House, or whether democrats control one of them.

2022

Once again republicans are at a numerical disadvantage. If they have not lost control of the Senate, they will now. Past history also says that democrats will gain control of the House.

After 2022

This is where the current course spells trouble for Trump. In the last 2 years of any President’s 2nd terms, the President has a problem. No other elected official cares what happens to him. Democrats will most likely control the Senate or the House, and congressional investigations will have had at least 4 years to find something. With no one else to defend him, his Presidency will be headed for disaster.

Conclusion

If we project out from where we are now, we can safely say democrats will control the Senate by 2022. The House will either be locked into a cycle of switching between parties or will progressively move to democrat control. (Did I make another pun?)

This means he will either lose re-election or end his 2nd term Nixon-like after 2022.

However, something will change before this. If the President get’s “lucky” with a good economy, foreign crises suited to him, or loss of democratic momentum, his presidency could become a better success. Otherwise, he has to become a better President.

His disaster will come sooner if he gets “unlucky” with a worse economy, badly run foreign crises, or we just “get tired of him”.

I’ll have to examine the individual scenarios in later posts, and of course, I will have to adjust the projection as I “hone”. Right now he’s on a slow slide into disaster. That could change, but guess which one I would bet on.

Monday, February 20, 2017

Counting the Congress

How I Count Senators to Evaluate President Trump

In Trump Watch, I outline three scenarios all of which depend on whether the Trump Presidency is perceived a success of a disaster. And, as I already pointed out, the only objective measure in the short term is how many legislators are willing to take action either for or against him.
The current count is 52 Success / 61 Disaster
So, now let's look into that.

The theory is that failures or successes of the Trump administration will eventually have electoral consequences to a congressman, which will, in turn, affect support. FiveThityEight is, in fact, tracking this through their votes. They call this the Trump Score, but to avoid confusion I will call it the 538 Trump Score. This is good info, and probably better than what I can give you. However, it does have a problem for our purposes. It does not come down to a single score.

Fortunately, (with some effort) I figured out how to export the numbers to a spreadsheet. For now, I'm looking at the Trump Plus-Minus, which is their predicted score minus the actual score. Currently, their average and median are almost 0 for all cases indicating, overall congressman are voting as predicted. However, that is only because both sides are highly partisan and voting as a block. And, so each side has deviated from their predicted score by about the same amount. I've detailed the numbers, here.

This in itself is a good measure, especially for telling if partisan solidarity is holding. However, it’s hard to see if Congress would be willing to take his lead or proactively take action against him.

There are his approval and favorability ratings. Certainly, these values are a precursor to his success or disaster. Why I'm not using them yet is the I'm not finding numbers I'm comfortable with, mostly because it's too soon. In particular, I've not been able to find aggregates broken by party affiliation or, better, states. Without this, I'm vulnerable to my being mislead like many where during the elections. However, as you will soon see, I will use them to validate or invalidate certain assumptions. More importantly, if I can get good numbers, I can revisit the mindsets I used before (re-evaluated by what we learned from the election).

So, we're back to counting congressman. The goal here is to get an estimate of the number of congressmen that are ‘independent' enough to go against their party. Mostly, because I can’t realistically count representatives I am sticking to senators. My defense for this is that the goals of the Senate and House are currently aligned so the Senate can be used as a proxy for the House.

Let’s consider the following scenario. The Senate Select Committee for Intelligence has ordered the White House not to destroy documents. What if in a couple of weeks, the Senate discovered documents were destroyed. We now have the same situation that harmed Nixon and Clinton. Would the Senate consider impeachment?

Unless McConnell and Ryan could get the votes, they would not even call for a vote. So, assuming President Trump's popularity has not changed, how many votes could the get?

That would be the Disaster Count.

Now, let’s take this another way. What if President Trump made a proposal that is consistent with his promises, but electorally dangerous to senators? For example, a large tax on imported goods. For now, assume the bill is well written and the President is able to articulate a good economic argument. (Can you believe I have to say that.) How many senators would fight for such a bill?

As before McConnell and Ryan would need to know they could get the votes to let there be a vote.

That would be the Success Count

So, the counts are derived by deciding how many senators are ‘countable' or not and then deciding which would support a ‘success' of ‘disaster'. The rest or 'base' is added to the counts for each scenario.

To be ‘countable’
  • The senator represents swing state or a state different from his party. As most do, this is defined by the vote margin for or against President Trump 
  • Or, the senator has demonstrated recent actions that show independence from the President and the Party. I will have to change this over time. So far, I'm just adding republicans with a 538 Trump Score bellow 100%. 
13 republican and 17 democratic senators represent swing states or states opposite their party.

Currently, only 4 republican senators have a 538 Trump Score bellow 100%. Only Rand Paul meets this criterion and has not already been listed as ‘countable'.

38 republicans and 31 democratic senators are NOT 'countable' and are the 'base'

You may have noticed that the scores are higher for both than my eyeball guess in the post, Trump Watch. I decided not to attempt the most conservative measure because I felt comfortable making the following assumptions.

As long as Presidents Trump’s popularity remains bellow 50%, and democrats solidarity remains strong, we can assume:
  1. All swing states can be considered democratic states 
  2. Republican senators not up for election in 2018 are free to be independent. This is reasonable because politicians have to have faith in their ability to campaign and can recover if there is enough time. 
  3. Even democratic senators in republican states will remain loyal to the democratic party. This is reasonable because of primary threats that are realistic under the current fervor. 
I have all this in detail, here. In addition, there is now a link on the top toolbar ‘Congress Count'. Please note that I cannot update these values regularly so pay attention to “Last updated ...”

You may ask, could a President be successful and have a low Success Count. Yes, since there have been successful presidents without help from Congress. Theodore Roosevelt and Harry Truman are good examples.

And could not a disaster happen before the Disaster Count shows it? Unfortunately, yes, especially with international scenarios.

Both these are why I have to continually make adjustments as events unfold. There’s my cowardly qualification. You’ve been warned.

Friday, February 10, 2017

Trump Watch

When Do We Know It’s Bad?

Will the Trump Presidency be a disaster, success, or threat?


I'm still not ready. I've done warm baths, therapy, distracting myself with video games, and drinking (a whole lot of drinking), and I'm still not ready to bear President Trump. I'm getting there. I don't avert my eyes from the TV when he's on anymore. (Though many close to me still do.) I even read some the news. I was just hoping I had more time, but everything is moving too fast.

Let's face it. You want me to talk about it. You want me to make some kind of estimate on how bad it will get. More importantly, you want to know when to apply for that Canadian visa (assuming we are not at war with them. Remember that they'll pick Australia's side over us.)

So, the way I see it, we are talking about three potential outcomes to watch for.
  1. A Disaster Presidency
  2. Amazing to most of us, a Successful Presidency
  3. Democratic progress is threatened, a Threatening Presidency.
Hopefully, I can maintain an updated guess on each of these and more important what will be the "tipping points" as in what to watch for.

The Disaster Presidency

I would define this as overrun with corruption and incompetence, an unnecessary international crisis or war, or massive economic hardship. This would include a financial crisis, suffering from changes to health care, an epidemic of riots, etc.

What helps is that there are previous examples of disaster presidencies. Examples are Grant, Harding, Nixon, and G.W. Bush. (Some would include Carter in this list as well, but you see the point.) However, in theses examples, three were re-elected. All have historian defenders, Even now, you will meet resistance criticizing Nixon and Bush. That is because there is some subjectivity (that war was totally necessary) and relativity (your president was more corrupt).

Whatever, the case, we will not get a consensus until long after we have passed on. Maybe not even then. However, we can get a majority. One of the best measures is (What's it called? Oh yeah.) elections, but we see how inaccurate the last one was. There are also approval ratings. Yeah I know we just had problems with polling as well. Perhaps the best measure in Congress.

Even if the presidency is broiled in disaster nothing will happen before 2020, unless Congress allows it. As of now, the bet is 'no', but that can change. And that is the real question, what will change it? Quite simply when will the majority of senators and representatives believe Trump is more harm to them than good. Simply put, would 218 representatives and 60 senators believe they must stop him to be re-elected

Counting representatives is too cumbersome and complicated, so instead, as a proxy, let's count the minimum senators that would never take power from him. If the count is comfortably bellow 60, he's safe. 60 or above he's on thin ice. 67 or above, he's one mistake away from impeachment.

My eyeball guess is 36. I'll get into this more in a future post.

Off the top of my head, tipping points include
  •  Conservative media no longer supports him
  •  Approval ratings drops bellow 35%
  •  Major republicans change parties

The Successful Presidency

Hey, who knows. I and about half the country could be wrong. Again, though, just like the Disaster Presidency, there will always be those who insists it's a success even as Russian soldiers are landing on our shores. So, we are back to using Congress again. Here I would count the number of senators that will vote for his initiatives no matter what. Bellow 50, times will be difficult for him. Above 60, he's only limited by his competency. My eyeball guess is 49. I'll get into this more in a future post.

A point to remember is that a Successful Presidency is not necessarily a republican success. There are a lot of scenarios where the Trump Presidency is remembered for progressive accomplishments (raising minimum wage, expansion of Medicare, return of unions, etc.) In fact, for reasons I'll go into later, success will most likely be a bipartisan success.

Off the top of my head, tipping points include
  • Approval ratings goes above 50%
  • New political candidates begin to imitate President Trump
  • Political parties restructure or new one forms

The Threatening Presidency

Note that during the election, I had looked at his' threat to democracy', while here I instead refer to 'democratic progress'. The difference is that 'threat to democracy' would describe changes that have no parallel in American history and would have a bipartisan agreement. But, that's a tall order.

America was less 'democratic' than toady, and we don't want that to return to then. I avoided describing the threat that way during the election because there's no bipartisan way to do so. My hope is that I can outline both conservative threats (such as permanent government takeover of businesses) and liberal threats (such as overt voter suppression), even if done separately. I'm looking for scenarios where at least one side would hate and the other would not like (or admit to liking). Good examples are internment camps and the return of Jim Crow. And of course, this would include out and out threats to democracy.

Long term effect is important here. In truth, I am more concerned about the President that follows Trump. And by the converse, my concern is less for action easily undone by the next president.

So how do we rank the chances and what are the tipping points

Off the top of my head, tipping points include
  • Approval ratings goes above 50%
  • New political candidates begin to imitate President Trump
  • Political parties restructure or new one forms
  • Governors commit constitutional abuses and the Federal Government does not stop it
  • Judge rulings are ignored with no consequences
  • Major news media outlets are closed with no pushback
  • Militia groups are allowed to commit violence with no real effort to stop them
If some of those are the same as a Successful Presidency, yeah that's the case. He has to be perceived successful to be a threat (otherwise, he's just a disaster). So you can think of a Threatening Presidency as a Successful Presidency Plus.

As for ranking the likelihood, I still can't come up with an objective measure. The closest I know of is the Doomsday Clock, but that is a subjective one. For now, I'll have to be subjective and just try the following.

In order to be threatening, President Trump has to meet three thresholds. Has to be willing to make an attempt. He has to be competent enough to succeed. And, none of our 'checks and balances' would stop him. I'll rank each of these as Very Low, Low, Medium, High, and Very High. Here are my first guesses.
  • Attempt: Medium
  • Competence: Low
  • No Check: High
Since all thresholds would have to be met, the overall rank is the lowest of all three. So, Low. 'll get into this more in (you guessed it) a future post

Monday, January 23, 2017

And So It Begins...

My 1st Predictions on the Trump Presidency

It's official. He is now President Trump. As much as I've been avoiding writing about him, I'm out of time and need to get at least of few predictions written down. So, here's my first one.

I'm going to get something wrong. There it is, my most cowardly qualification ever. But, I still don't have enough data to predict with any confidence. However, if I don't do it now, I'll be relating history not making predictions. Otherwise, I would not be writing this.

Of course, if all the other predictions come true, then this 1st prediction will be wrong. But, then I'll have gotten all, including the 1st, predictions right. But, then this one would be wrong... OK. Now you see why I don't get invited to parties.

Now let's point out a prediction of sorts that's already come true. During the transition period, he had difficulty getting good people. I totally called it and a lot of people are giving me credit, right down to hiring Christie to lead the transition. Sad. The question is whether issues persists or did negative press and nomination hearings produce a more reliable staff.

Okay, enough patting myself on the back. Let me start now with my most confident predictions.

The Next Four Years Will Be Noisy

President Trump, whether intentional or not, has shown the tactic of adding controversy when under criticism. He's OK with bad press as long as he originated it. Consider his reaction to bad press on his transition team and cabinet picks, a complaint on twitter on how Pence was treated at Hamilton. Inconsequential bad press drowns out legitimate criticism is the lesson learned. The question is whether or not we will get tired of it. Traditional politicians avoid bad press because it persists negative feelings that hurt you in the futures. So, far President Trump has not paid this cost, but four years is a long time.

In fact, one reason I've been quiet is that I've been trying to learn how to filter the noise. I recommend you do so, also. (If only those in the media read my blog.)

Small Victories Will Be Trumpeted. Significant Problems Will Be Defamed.

For example, Any company deciding to not export jobs will be credited to the President, while higher unemployment will be called 'fake news'. If you are a Trump supporter and still suffering, this might not work, but if you're OK but worried about the future, it will.

The Deficit Will Increase More Than Under President Obama.

President Trump has shown little concern with fiscal responsibility and wants to give a lot without asking a lot. The only way this does not happen is if republicans are willing to stop him. So far, they have not shown such fortitude.

His Staff Will Contradict Him

I don't know if this was intentional or has just been a lucky outcome. Trump will make an outrageous promise, while those under him claim he did not mean it or even that he flat out never said it (even when there's tape).  Note the Vice-Presidential date. Instead, of either him or his staff being held accountable, the message gets muddled and supporters hear what they want to hear. The question is which message results in action and does this lead to conflict with him and his staff.

Now some that I see happening, but have less confidence.

Russia Will Be the Beginning of the End

President Trump's unwillingness to speak against Putin confounds me, and I don't think he sees the pitfalls of doing so. No, this is not going to turn the masses against him, but that's not where the danger lies. He's in conflict with republicans on many issues, but their behavior during the election showed they were not as committed to their principles as they claimed. Nor, has Trump shown much commitment to pushing any particular agenda. So, most can be spun as a win for either side. (How voters respond is a different question).

What makes Russia different is that there are at least three senators (Rubio, McCain, and Lindsey) that care deeply about America's strong international presence, including opposition to Russia. They have practically defined their careers by this. Remember that it only takes three senators to block President Trump. These three have good reason to hate him and each has run for president. This is pivotal because it's likely to be the first time President Trump unquestionably loses a fight and given his bullying behavior that could cause others to fight him on other issues.

Even if does not occur, it's hard to imagine two strong-willed, competitive men like Trump and Putin not running into conflict. Then, what happens? Does Putin use the same cyber resources against him? If in fact, he was more interested in disrupting American democracy, than getting Trump elected, he will turn on him anyway. No, I don't think that would directly hurt President Trump, but again, what happens to bully after someone stands up to him.

That there will be a confrontation, I have confidence. That it will create long-term consequences for President Trump, I have less but pay attention. The effect may not show immediately.

Let Me Wrap Up Now

I have more, but that's enough for now. But, before I go let me point out where one of my past claims could go wrong. I made a big deal that who became president would not change the Supreme Court nominations. One flaw in my logic is that McConnell may be willing to end the filibuster (for Supreme Court nominations only). It makes sense that he would. Democrats will stop the nominations, otherwise, and given the numbers, he's likely to keep a Senate majority until 2020. However, my hunch is that he still won't. I give it a 50-50, not enough to bet on either way.

That will be all for now. I'll add more as I learn more.