Showing posts with label Of Special Note. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Of Special Note. Show all posts

Friday, May 12, 2017

A Biased Morning

This is going to be quick, and I can only touch the surface. But, this morning was such a good example of what biased and unbiased news sounds like.

At 8 AM I listened for about 5 minutes each to the following:

1. NPR News Recap Podcast
2. Beginning of "Morning Joe"
3. Beginning of "Fox & Friends"

Here's what's was on each and how they are biased.

NPR News Recap - Unbiased News

That President Trump contradicted the original reason for firing Comey in the most anodyne language possible. And...

That China is considering allowing the import of hamburger from the US, and in exchange, the US will allow cooked chicken to come from the China.

Morning Joe - Left-Biased Opinion Show

That President Trump and his spokesman have been lying (actually used that word) about Comey being fired. The Republican Senators are being used. Joe Scarborough spoke in particularly condemning language.

Fox & Friends - Right-Biased Opinion Show

Geraldo Rivera gave a long tortured explanation saying that the Russian Investigation will not lead to anything, and if the collision happened, it is not a crime (entirely misleading). He did so in as close to as scholarly a voice as he is capable of.

Then a guest came on to report how China and US may improve trade (the same news NPR reported). He then followed on how no one else is reporting this, again to discredit the Comey news.

In Summary

First, I have to point out that there is a difference between a news show and an opinion show, so you can't condemn "Morning Joe" and "Fox & Friends" for being more biased than "NPR News". Also, both examining the content and how they are biased deserves more discussion than I can give at the moment.

This was just too good an example for me to wait until I can discuss news bias in depth. The main takeaway is that bias is more about emphasis than content and noting how "Fox & Friend" complains about news not being reported that had just been reported by NPR.

Tuesday, May 9, 2017

Republicans, There's Something On Your Shoe

How the AHCA Hurts Republicans

So, we have a new republican health care bill, and there is a lot of celebrating on both side. So, who’s right? Will this be the doo doo on the republican’s shoes? Could this swing the 2018 elections?

It’s early. Really early. But, maybe can look at some signs and trends.

Bad Signs for Republicans

I've been looking at what conservative media been saying, and they are not talking about it as much as liberal. From what I’ve could see, the passage of the AHCA is being reported on, but not analyzed on Fox News as much as on MSNBC. Instead, Fox News wants to talk about something else. That’s a sign that they don’t think their audience is liking what they hear. Considering that this could be touted as an ant-Obama accomplishment, like the Supreme Court, there should be some trumpeting (pun intended).

The second bad sign is that I'm only hearing defensive arguments from republicans. Their message is about how it’s not as bad as the democrats are saying, the Senate will fix it, etc. If you told that to your boss, would he be thinking you did a good job?

Bad Signs for Democrats

They’re happy. Yeah, I know that sounds counter-intuitive, but have you noticed that republicans are almost never happy, at least not for long. That’s because anger and fear are more motivating than happiness and satisfaction. It’s one of the reasons republicans win even when most of the country is against them. Instead of gloating, democratic politicians and pundits should be screaming in outrage and how we cannot let this continue. Gloating makes your supporters relax and, worse, can galvanize the other side, even if they are being screwed by their own.

This happened in May, not November. There’s lots of time for republicans, not to fix the bill, but fix their message. Just as bad, there’s lots of time for democrats to get it wrong, which they have a history of doing.

What We Need to Consider and Still Watch For

After the 1st Delusion of Politics, there is the 2nd Delusion of Politics, “politics should be fair”. Saying politics is not fair is stating the obvious. But, here’s what we forget. Complaining about fairness only motivates people that are already on your side. Those in the middle think both sides are unfair, and the other side thinks you deserve it.

Right now, the republicans are hoping to be treated “fairly”. They want us to remember that the Senate will change it. That provisions will not happen immediately. This is the responsibility of state governments. That Obamacare was going to fail anyway. Yes, republican Delusionals will all believe that. No one else will care.

Passing the bill did worse than doing nothing because it showed us they can do something. Now, arguing that it is Obama’s fault is like me saying the previous owner of my car is still responsible for changing the oil. Republicans are now responsible for every premium increase, deductible increase, and policy denial, even if the bill never passes or no measures take effect before 2018.

Is that fair? No, it isn’t. What goes wrong with healthcare in the next year and a half could have nothing to do with what Republicans did or could do. Does not matter. It was not fair for President Obama, either.

What republicans have going for them is that they can makes this up with other bills. One of the more politely rational arguments for passing the AHCA is that it makes lowering taxes in the next bill easier. If it’s visible to lower-class and middle-class taxpayers, those not liking the AHCA could still like republicans.

And what they also have going for them is what they always have going for them. They’re Delusionals outnumber democrat Delusional. The AHCA may hurt those that voted for Trump, but they may not see it that way. And those, may not be the voters that are part of the smaller midterms electorate. However, that is why we need to know how conservative media is reporting on this. Those voters are not as loyal to their congressman as they are to Fox News and Rush Limbaugh. That conservative media hasn’t yet, is a bad sign for republicans.

Therefore, I would recommend to democrats to focus on the AHCA increasing costs for older people, who do vote in midterms. If you’re worried about younger voters, there's more than enough reasons for them to vote against republicans. Remember that those willing to take away healthcare won't think twice about taking away help for student loans. (Yeah, that got your attention.)

This is where democrats need to be careful. Too many offensive comments or talk of single-payer can be just what conservative media is looking for, and that could be enough to maintain or even increase support for republicans.

And in the same way, democrats need to keep their voters motivated on this. If democrats cannot get voters to turn out on healthcare, they won’t be able to on Planned Parenthood, Russia, or any other issue. So, we should keep watching to see if democrats stay motivated.

I could once again point out that it’s way too early to make predictions on the 2018 Election, but I really can’t back out in the last paragraph. Even I would not make that cowardly a qualification. So, I will definitively say this hurts republican chances of keeping the House more than it helps. And this is already in an environment where history and conventional wisdom says they are at a disadvantage. I would say it pushes their chances down to a totally made up 30% of keeping the House. But remember, as I kept warning, those were the same odds Trump had of becoming president.

Saturday, October 15, 2016

When Can We Say Trump Will Not Be President?

Trump is Losing Big Time, But Has He Lost?

Trump has had the worst three weeks I've seen in a presidential election. He's lost two debates. As of now at least 9  women have come forward accusing him of sexual misconduct. Everything I know or heard about politics says he can't win continuing what he's doing. Especially with only 3 weeks left. So when can we view him as lost.

Never. I am never going to say that. I won't jinx it. I am not going to be convinced he's lost until Nov 8th. Maybe not until Nov 9th.

All hysterics aside, of course, he has a chance to win. I can tell you how much, 15% to 20%. In conventional terms, Trump currently needs to take 6 states away from Clinton and not lose any. (Note that's easier than it sounds. States tend to change together so changing 6 states is not 6 times as hard as changing 1.)

So, how does it look like the story play out?

Trump continues campaigning in a way that will only get about 40% of the vote. At the 3rd Debate, Trump stay true to form belligerent and temperamental . On election day, Clinton wins with over 300 electoral votes,

So, how would this change?

The 3rd Debate

This is the most likely point Trump could change the race. First, Trump will have a chance to bring out choice Wikileaks reveals. Clinton has probably prepared for this, but in the past has not always dealt with this situation well. Of course, Trump will have the same issue when he has to answer for his accusations of sexual misconduct.

Trumpys are so Shy

There is a prevailing theory put forth by Trump surrogates that polls are under reporting Trump support, the Shy Trump Voter theory. The argument is that negative attitude towards Trump cause voters to lie to pollster.

Of course, there are problem with this theory. First, looking at a Trump rally, tweets on twitter, internet forums, and just asking for help at Walmart, you don't get the impression that Trumpys are shy. Second, I can just as easily argue for Shy Clinton voters, republicans who don't want to see Trump elected but can't admit they're voting for Clinton. (In other words, Jebs). And finally, the mechanics of polling trying to account for demographics and turnout has a better chance to overweight the polls towards Trump. This is a fact in at least one case.

The combinations of arguments really say there is more uncertainty in the polls than reported. But, let's say the Shy Trump Voter theory is true. The biggest supporting evidence is a discrepancy between online polls and live interview polls. This could give Trump an extra 2% to 3%.

Low Turnout

Driving low turnout is the traditional way candidates win when they are down in the polls. Answering a poll is easier than going to vote, and if one side is motivated more than the other they can win even when down in the polls. Clinton has trouble being a motivating candidate, while Trump supporters sure are motivated.

This is the most reasonable explanation for Trump's negative campaigning. Negative campaigning tends to hurt both candidates, but he's already pushed as low as he can go, Negative campaigning can only hurt Clinton.

The problem is that it's one thing to rely on turnout when you're only a couple of points down. As of today, Clinton is up by 6% to 7%, Clinton also spent time beforehand to counter this. The reason you setup a "ground game", to turnout her vote. Finally, this strategy boxes Trump in and could limits what he can achieve in the 3rd Debate.

Bottom Line

Trump can still win. It's hard but he can do it. If he has a good enough showing in the 3rd Debate and there are Shy Trump voters, he could get close enough to Clinton that turnout decides the race. So, I"m still drinking until at least Oct 20th and probably after Nov 9th.


Tuesday, October 11, 2016

Trump Will Not Decide the Next Supreme Court Justice, Nor Will Clinton

Everyone Forgets About the Filibuster

Trump will not decide the next Supreme Court Justice, Nor will Clinton

Trump is not a true conservative. Do I need the argue that? He has constantly flipped on issues with no clear allegiance to the conservatism or the Constitution. But, many are are willing to look past that because, he has agreed to appoint a conservative judge to the Supreme Court. If that is the main or only reason you are voting for Trump, find another.

What seems to be forgotten is that nominees for the Supreme Court can be filibustered. And the chance that Trump will have a supermajority is infinitesimal, Of the 34 senators up for re-election, 24 are republican. The odds are currently about 50% that republicans can keep a majority. The odds that republican keep their current number is only 5%. Forget the chances that there will be 60.

So, even if the Senate is held, the next Supreme Court Justice will need 6 to 10 democrats to agree. If the democrats even allow Trump to appoint a justice, he will not be a Scalia. He will not be on the list Trump holds out as a bribe for conservative votes. The next justice will be a moderate.

The good news for conservatives (or bad news for liberals) is that for Clinton, it will be no difference.

But what if the Senate Majority Leader ends the filibuster, at least for SCOTUS nominees. That is also extremely unlikely. To begin with, it would be foolishness for if a democratic Majority Leader, most likely, Chuck Schumer. In 2018, the democrats are unlikely to hold on to the Senate, for the same reason it's so difficult for republicans this election. Democrats will want the filibuster then.

If Senator McConnell is the Senate Majority leader he could end the filibuster, knowing he is likely to hold the Senate for at least 4 years. But that would be out of character for him. First, Senator McConnell has made every indication that he cherishes the traditions of the Senate, including the filibuster. And besides, his past actions show, he'll want to keep it BECAUSE the President is republican. Senator McConnell has relied on avoiding controversial bills by pointing to the Presidential Veto. He does not have to ask Senators to make those votes because they'll just be vetoed. With a Republican President he'll need the filibuster to keep that same excuse. If you doubt me looked at what happened the only Obama's veto was overridden.




If you are taking a devils bargain for the Supreme Court you want, here is what your real bargain is. You get a president who's proudly lived a life of decadence, shown no allegiance to conservatism, constantly makes proposals that would end the Reagan Revolution, brags about breaking promises, and lacks moral courage.

For all that, at best you get Justice Kennedy.

Sunday, October 9, 2016

The Final Stretch

Did Everything Change After Labor Day?

On Sep 23rd Cruz endorses Trump. Oct 7th, he wished could take it back.
On Sep 23rd Cruz endorses Trump. Oct 7th, he wished could take it back.

I've been saying for a while now, that more voters are expected to pay attention after Labor Day. Does that mean what I posted in Just Who is Voting for Who changed? Could be. Let's take a look.

Clinton
Low and Natural 2-way Sep 17th 44%
                4-way          40%
High            2-way Oct  4th 48%
                4-way          44%

As you can Clinton reached the same High Point and here Low Point was her Natural Point. So far, Clinton has not had any true negative press (at least at a time not overshadowed by Trump's) She probably has not hit a low yet. The evidence right now is that her coalition has not changed.

Trump

Low     2-way Oct  7th 43%
        4-way          41%
Natural 2-way Sep 17th 44%
        4-way          40%
High    2-way Oct  2nd 45%
        4-way          41%

His High Point is also not out of line with before. As for his Low Point, you can see the effect the 1st Debate and following week. If you read my post about it (or just breathed air), you know what I mean.



But, given just how bad he was, the Low Point is not that low, 41% 4-way, versus the 35% before. This suggests that either he is still holding on to about half of his Hopeys or more voters for him entered the electorate after Labor Day. The latter is unlikely because Clinton is still holding on to her percentage of the electorate.

And of course, these polls do not include what effect the video of Trump's lewd comment's has done, but well get into this later.

Poor Johnny

Hey, did you know other parties beside Republican and Democrat? Well there are, and they're getting between 8% to 12% of the vote. So, if that starts to change, it could change the race. That change may be going on now.

First, there's a normal shift away from Third Party voting as the election gets closer. When that pollsters call six months before the election, it's easy to say I want Gary Johnson. But as it get closer you begin to realize that voting for Gary Johnson really means indirectly voting for Trump or Clinton.

But the second, problem is that we've had a chance to see Gary Johnson. (Oh yeah, Gary Johnson that's the "What's Aleppo?" guy). On Sep 28th. the night before the 1st Debate, he did a forum on Chris Matthew, and did not come off well. Some might say even "Sara Palinish".


If you saw this, your belief that Johnson was an alternative to Trump or Clinton just got tested. As for Jill Stein, she had throughout the election only been marginal and made equally disqualifying performances. Before, I had given 8% for the No-Way-No-Hows, the group that includes Third Party voters. Has that changed?



If you look at the yellow and green lines, there is a slow downfall in both lines, but not really a change after the Sep 28th, when Johnson made such a poor performance. So, far the No-Way-No-Hows are staying. It's hard to see in the chart, however, but Johnson did make a sudden dip to 6.5% these past couple of days. Like most of what's happening now, we just have to keep watching.

If their is a change in the No-Way- No-Hows, it should not go lower than 5%. Since May, the total of Johnson and Stein vote in a single poll, never went bellow that number. Just as important their all time high is about 12%. Here are the numbers.

        Highest Avg  Lowest Avg  Lowest Poll
Johnson       9%          5%          4%
Stein         5%          2%          1%

The Unspoken Winner

If you've been paying attention (OK start paying attention now), Clinton was always the favorite. Trump is clearly trapped in the Great Delusion of Politics and Clinton is not. And, the polls are showing this. On his best days he's only tied, and only once pulled marginally ahead. In fact, their “natural” points, 45 vs 44, makes Clinton the natural favorite.

However, there’s a big difference between winning and having won.This is why no one has been talking about her as the favorite. Trumpys can't believe it. Hopeys are still hoping. Borings don't want to become complacent. And Excitables want to insist they still have options.

At 45 vs 44, (their Natural Points),  Trump has about a 45% chance of being President. Even, when Clinton is +3% ahead, he has a about a 40% chance. Personally, I need his chances to go down to 30% before I can stop drinking and 20% before I can go off my meds.

The Demographic Appeal

At some point I should have mapped how political shows describe voters to the current mindsets. Well, I tried. I just could not find a poll aggregator that subdivided the answers demographically. Furthermore, most analysis cannot work from polls in this election. Instead, they use how votes were divided last election. I find this questionable because Clinton is not Obama and Trump is not Romney.

But, I've held off as long as I can. I'll just have to fudge it. This late in the game I don't need to go into all the categories, so let's just focus on the highlights.

Young Voters and Jebs (Clinton's Excitables)
Most young voters (18 to 30) are voting for Clinton, but their not excited about it. They actually want a candidate to offer something other than "I'm not Trump". (Yeah, how dare they.) However, there are also the Jebs out. They could vote for her, if she showed some willingness to take on Republican causes. She has the classic political dilemma. She can't make young voters and Jebs happy. From her past statements, she chose the young voters.

Whites and Non-Whites
Needless to say, Trump he has done a lot this year to alienate non-whites. But, just as important, educated whites are turned off by his behavior, especially women. (Hopeys and Wait-n-Sees) His dilemma is that Trumpys like the fact that he is "politically incorrect", so he can only walk back his comments so far. He's made outreach, which did more to calm Hopeys and Wait-n-Sees, but Clinton countered by pointing out his association to the Alt-Right.

Women
Democrats usually win the women vote, but they don't always win the educated white women vote. This is a significant chunk of Trumps Hopeys and the Wait-n-Sees. The fact that Trump might not win enough women voters has been a concern of Hopeys from the beginning.

Back to Trump

Trump's had a bad week. He failed to show temperament in the debate and compounded the mistake throughout the week. But, he's still holding at 43%. Shouldn't he be lower? What's going on?

Maybe there's not enough time
Trump did start at a high for him, 45%, and last time it took about 12 days to reach his bottom. It's only been 7.

He pulled some third party vote
Johnson's all time high is was around 9%. His last polling average was 6.5%. Trump could have pulled 3% from there, (I doubt any went from Stein to Trump)

We got used to him
This is the most disturbing possibility and was from the beginning. With each of Trump's downfalls, his bottom was slightly higher.



His 43% could be his new percentage of Trumpys. Well, at least before there was a video tape.

Trump's Potty Mouth

I'm sure I don't need to describe the video. I don't want to describe it. Go look it up for yourself. I'll just add that what he said was indefensible. Like I needed a reason to dislike Trump. Instead, I'll talk about why others have changed their mind.

Now imagine you're a Hopey. Trump does not seem to respect your beliefs or party. He behaves in ways that make you ashamed. However, you don't want Clinton to win, and just as important you want to keep the Senate and Supreme Court. Trump might not be what you want, but Clinton, you know you don't. The implication here is that you have to believe Trump can win.

Let's add that you know at least what we know. Clinton has always been the favorite, and Trump can't win until he convinces non-Trumpys he has the right temperament and appeals to more voters, especially women. Then, you see Trump have questionable temperament in front of 90 million viewers, and he compounds it with unnecessary juvenile antics throughout the week.

It's too late to change. Election Day is only a month away. This is who you need to win, so you hold on to hope that Trump can do better in the 2nd Debate. Then a video tape comes out that you know enrages most women in America.

I just described what every republican politician is feeling this weekend.

What makes this weekend different from previous Trump scandals is the way republican professionals are reacting. We can't know the impact on voters for a week, and the professionals don't have that kind of time. When they begun denouncing Trump and calling for him to step down, there was no turning back. The support Trump lost this weekend is lost for good.

On to the 2nd Debate

Tonight we could see the end of the Trump campaign. He might continue on to Election Day, but we all will know tonight as the night he lost. And then again, he might also save it.

But before we get to that, we need to talk about the latest Clinton "scandal", Fortunately, for her everyone is focused on Trump, but Wikileaks revealed more Clinton secrets. The biggest threat to her is that it might anger younger voters (Excitables). There's a lot, but most of it's mild, so I won't try to go through it here. Let's see how the debate goes.

I just want you to know that if you see Clinton making some appeals to young voters, this is why. And, just as likely she may bring up Russia preemptively. The Wikileaks info came from Russian hackers, and by pointing out Trump's bromance with Putin, she brings Wikileaks veracity into question. I also expect her to make constant appeals to women voters, of course.

And then there's Trump. We know that's what the night will be about. The political shows are going into painful detail as to what he needs to do, and how they don't expect him to do it. For me, I'm watching to see how he treats the audience. I seriously am wondering if he will yell at someone.

To Sum Up

I went over a lot here, and I may not have tied it together well so, let me attempt fix that.
  • We are still waiting to see how low Trump can go. Will he go all the way to 35% or did he increase his Trumpys? Given that he is now in a war with the Republican Party, this could become the only vote he gets.
  • Are No-Way-No-Hows about to shift to either candidate?
  • Clinton still has to worry about keeping her Excitables motivated, and the recent Wikileaks reveal could hurt this.
You'll know more when I do.

Sunday, October 2, 2016

Just Who is Voting for Who?

What is the Make Up of Trump and Clinton Support


In the The Good, the Bad, and the Delusional and How to get Voters, the Gadfly Way, I went on to describe the mindset of voters and in general how candidates form their coalition. Now there's a lot of background here, so if you haven't already read those links, you need to buck up. If you try to wing it, you'll end up sniffling like Trump in a debate.

Time to Look at the Polls

It's not like you can go and ask "Are you delusional and voting for Clinton". The art is to look for significant events in the poll and see if you can infer mindsets from this.

Here's my amateur take. So, once again, our old friend, charts from Real Clear Politics,


Let's look at the two "Natural Points", the first and last lines in the chart. The first line is when head-to-head polls settled during the primaries. You can think of this as their first impressions. This was about 45 Clinton to 44 Trump. The last line is where polls settled after Labor Day. The common wisdom is that most voters don't pay attention until after this. (I don't buy that but let's go with it.) You will notice that is also 45 Clinton to 44 Trump.

So, these two points can be thought of as to where the electorate goes if allowed to settle over time. Part of the idea, is that we really don't change our first impressions, and all the play between these two point is just rationalization of what we feel.

That aside, we can use this to infer their natural coalitions. In other words, if voters are not being swayed by events, campaigning, gaffs, etc, Clinton gets 45 and Trump get 44. (If this panics you, wait. There's more to go).

Before we go further. There is a flaw with this chart. Note the green lines in the graph above. They mark the End of the Primaries and Labor Day, both times when who's following the election and methods of polling significantly change. I have some defense of this because the Natural points match. Fortunately only one data point, Clinton's High of 50, happened before the End of the Primaries. So, we'll just save that for now and bring it in later.

We really can't do post Labor Day because the time is too short. So, let's look from the End of the Primaries. (You will see another reason for doing this later)



So here's the breakdown

Trump
                   Trump   Clinton Undecided
Low      Jun 17th  38.3%    44.1%    17.6%
Natural  Sep 17th  43.9%    44.9%    11.2% 
High     Jul 27th  45.7%    44.6%     9.7%

Clinton
                  Clinton   Trump  Undecided
Low      Jul 15th  43.1%    40.4%    17.6%
Natural  Sep 17th  44.9%    43.9%    16.5% 
High     Aug 27th  48.4%    42.1%     9.5%
High (P) Mar 23rd  50.0%    38.8%    11.2%

However, these polls do not include Third Party. For our purposes, whether Libertarian or Green Party does not matter. Instead, this is a place holder for those opting out of voting. By the way, these polls don't start until after the End of the Primaries. (See what I did there).



Trump
                           Trump   Clinton Undecided  3rd
Low     4-way Jun 17th     35.3%    40.0%   16.1%     8.6%
        2-way              38.3%    44.1%   17.6%
Natural 4-way Sep 17th     40.3%    41.3%    7.2%    11.3%
        2-way              43.9%    44.9%   11.2% 
High    4-way Jul 27th     40.2%    40.4%    9.2%    10.2%
        2-way              45.7%    44.6%    9.7%

Clinton
                          Clinton  Trump  Undecided   3rd
Low     4-way Jul 30th     38.8%   40.0%    10.9%    10.3%
        2-way              43.7%   43.3%    13.0%
Low     4-way Jul 15th     40.3%   36.3%    12.9%    10.5%
        2-way              43.1%   40.4%    16.5%
Natural 4-way Sep 17th     41.3%   40.3%     7.2%    11.3%
        2-way              44.9%   43.9%    11.2% 
High    4-way Aug 8-12th   44.0%   37.0%     7.0%    12.0%
        2-way              48.0%   41.0%    11.0%
High    4-way Aug 27th     42.0%   38.0%     9.5%    11.4%
        2-way              48.4%   42.1%     9.5%
High (P)      Mar 23rd     50.0%   38.8%    11.2%

So What was Going On

To make sense of the numbers. Let's look at what's going on at those times. Remember that these polls represent what happened about a week to a month before.

March 23rd, Clinton's Highest point ever 50%
Around this time was the Brussels attack. Clinton held herself well, while Trump declared he needed no advise because of "his very good brain" and began a twitter war about Tedd Cruz's wife. (You can't make this up).

June 17th, Trump's Low point 35% 2-way and 38% 4-way
This was about the time Trump said Judge Curiel was biased against him because he was Mexican. Remember that Republican Partisans were counting on him to conform at this time. This is one of those rare times a candidate can drive even Partisans away.

July 15th, Clinton's Low 2-way point , 43% 2-way and 40% 4-way
FBI had released  results of the email server investigation which easily explains a low point,

July 27th, Trump's High 2-way point , 46% 2-way and 40% 4-way
This was at the time of the RNC a common High Point for any candidate. The messaging however offered very little for Republican Pragmatists and Idealists. This can explain the low 4-way number which is strange considering this is a high point.

July 30th, Clinton's Low point 4-way, 44% 2-way, 39% 4-way
The RNC had just happened providing a week of anti-Clinton campaigning, and the DNC Wikileak scandal had broken. This is also before Sanders had conceded. Idealists are the most like to be troubled by this.

August 8th thru 12th Clinton's High 4-way point, 48% 2-way, 44% 4-way
This was just after the DNC and was also around when Trump started his feud with the Khan family. Then a guy called the Gadfly Scholar started a blog, so obviously that change the entire race.

August 27th Clinton's High 2-way point, 48.4% 2-way, 42% 4-way
Very mixed time. Multiple stories about the Clinton Foundation, but this also is the time Manifort resigned, and Trump had to retool his campaign. Later he began hs outreach to African Americans, and Clinton responded speaking against the Alt-Right.

What Does All Means

Guessing their 'base' (Delusionals + Partisans) is straight forward. These are the voters that stay no matter what, so we just look at the candidate's worst days. Trump's is 35% and Clinton's if 39%.to 40%. We then look at those events to see if we can infer more.

Trumps Base
On June 17th, Trump had just become the presumptive nominee, and his, then, campaign manager Manifort had swayed nervous Republicans to believe Trump would be become more disciplined and conform. No one expected him to turn into a staunch Republican, but they did think he was smart and politically adept enough to work with them. Trump's attack on Judge Curiel torpedoed that idea.This indicates to me that Trump's base are mostly Delusionals.

From this event we can say that most Republican Partisans and Idealists were changed to Republican Pragmatists. So let's call his base, of mostly Delusionals, "Trumpys" and voters leaning to him "Hopeys" (as in they hope Trump stops being Trump).

Clinton's Base
July 15th was the most damaging time of her email scandal. Except for criminality, FBI Director Comey validated the worst suspicions of the scandal. However, if you look at the 2-way number, 43, she did not go down that much compared to her Natural point, 45. The bigger drop was her 4-way number indicating that her "natural" voters went to Third Party.

This analysis is supported by her Low point on July 30th, though the time is muddled. She should of had a good week with the DNC coming up. However, this was close enough to Comey's speech for the bad feelings to linger. The RNC, also, had a week to push this scandal  and any other criticisms of her. More importantly this was the time of the DNC leak, which certainly would anger Idealists still adjusting to the Sander's loss.

Let's call her 'base' "Borings" and voters leaning towards her "Excitables".

Trump's High Point
July 27 was the RNC, and that it was his High point is almost cliche. However, the number is only slightly higher than his Natural point, 46 vs 44, and his 4-way number remained low with no changed in Undecideds. In other words, all he did was rally his Trumpys and Hopeys and added some Pragmatists.

When, Clinton reached her Highest point of 48%, we can look at that as 52% would not vote for her under any circumstances. That would represent his Hopeys. However, we have to remove the base of Third Party voters, which I eye-balled as 8%. That gives us 9% Hopeys.

Another way to look at this is to ask: on his worst day,  how many votes went to Clinton. Looking at her 4-way number on that day, it's was typical, 40%. In other word, from his Natural Point, 44%, no votes went to Clinton. The  Natural point minus the Third Party base, 8%, confirms my previous guess of 9% Hopeys.

But that was her post primary High Point. If instead we use her most high, 50%, then we end up with 7% Hopeys.

Clinton's High Points
Her first High point, the 2nd week of August, was the DNC. Her later High point was more of a muddled time when Clinton campaigned against Trump's new efforts to "pivot". The difference between the two is mostly in the 4-way numbers. Both times drew Pragmatist, but the DNC rallied more Excitables.

Just as we did with Trump, we can use his high to estimate her Excitables giving us 7%. This is also close to what we get taking her Natural point and subtracting the Third Party base. 6%.

So Here are the Numbers
Here is my guess of their coalitions. Following my irrelevant labeling we'll call the True Pragmatists "Wait-n-Sees" and Third Party voters "No-Way-No-Hows"

Trump
35% Trumpys (Delusionals)
7% to 9% Hopeys (Partisans + Partisan-Pragmatists + Idealists)

Clinton
39% Borings (Delusionals + Partisans + Partisan-Pragmatists)
6% to 7% Excitables (Idealists)

Other
8% No-Way-No-Hows (Third Party)
2% to 5% Wait-n-Sees (True Pragmatists)

Now these number are going to be in flux and amount to my eye-ball, conjectured guess, so we can't treat these numbers as "real", Instead, these just give us the relative strength of their mindests. You've been warned.

Saturday, September 24, 2016

Scaredy Trump Face

Theses are the Body Language Tells I Observed During the Commander-In-Chief Forum

Trump shows his scaredy face when having to answer a serious question.



As mentioned previously, I found some body language that indicates when Trump is scared and lying, so I clipped some video for you to see. If you can, watch them with and without the sound. Obviously, they are from the Commander-in-Chief forum aired September 7th 2016.

How to Detect Scaredy Trump Face

Mostly look at his eyes as they try to widen and squint at the same time. This is by far the biggest indication. He also speaks slightly faster, but that can be hard to hear because he normally speaks fast. In addition, he constantly glances away. When Trump is comfortable he tends to lean towards who he is talking. Again this can be hard to see because Trump moves his head a lot.

The first video is when he was asked "What's next?" if we successfully remove ISIS from Iraq. This is also where he said we should have taken the oil. His response is laden with fear at the idea of actually having to answer factually.

Note that his questioner is not responding well, which is probably why Trump is being thrown off. I also suspect this make Trump look through the crowd for approval from someone else.




He also shows the same behavior when asked about his "secret ISIS plan". Note how Trump looks startled when Matt Lauer first says the work "ISIS".



Finally, the most important one. The 'tells' are harder to see, but this is him answering if he is prepared to be president. The biggest tell is just before Trump speaks If I'm reading his body language correctly, he's not just scared to answer the question, he is scared to actually be president. Consider what that means.



How to Detect Lyin Trump Face

So how can you tell Trump is lying. Obviously, his lips are moving. (Que old joke groan).

Trump shows classic lying ques. First he tends to quickly glance up to his right when describing a memory. The theory is that he is engaging his left brain to construct fake memory rather than recalling a real one.

More telling is for a split second he smiles. You have to pay attention to see it, especially since he does similar facial expression. But, this is the most reliable 'tell'.

I this one, he is doing his most classic lie, "I was against the Iraq War". He shows the 'tell' on the word "was" in the sentences. "To hear Hillary says I WAS not against the war". 


In this case, the 'tells' are harder to see, but it is worth watching because it;s when he is talking about his intelligence briefing and shows him trying to construct a lie in the moment. You will see him make a strong glance up to his right on the word "what" in the phrase "WHAT our experts".


Now Trump could be the most blatantly liar in American history. He certainly is in my lifetime. You would be right to ask why bother when we only need to see if he is breathing.

Sure, but what we don't know is if he realizes he is lying. If I'm reading the body language correctly, at some level he does.

Let finish by stating I am only a rank amateur at reading body language, so take what I say with that in mind. Trump is a very emotive speaker, so I could easily be making "false positives." I leave you to judge.

I also have to point out the everyone looks bad under this kind of analysis. However, Trump often relies upon an image of invincibility to trick and manipulate. Anything that pierces that is worthwhile. Again, I leave you to judge.





Wednesday, September 21, 2016

How Soon We Forget

Now is Just Not that Bad

No one died in Charlote, NC riot, 2016-9-21. Over 60 died in the 1992 L.A. Riot
4,000 California Army National Guardsmen patrolled the city to enforce the law

I'd like you now to look up two relatively obscure movies, Gung Ho (1986) and Dutch (1991). If you can, watch them. If not, at least read their plots on Wikipedia. I'll wait.

I hope you noticed. Gung Ho was about losing American jobs to globalism. A significant turning point in Dutch is when they meet a family in a homeless shelter. Note that the family in Dutch were not aberrations, and the father had a good job. They lost their home due to the 1990's Recession caused by the shift to a Post Cold War economy.

Note the dates.

Gung Ho was during the Reagan Administration that is so often invoked with the glow of nostalgia as a time of plenty and growth. Long before NAFTA. Long before Trump uttered the words "because of China". During Reagan's first term, unemployment had reach 10%, and was the first time most Americans ever heard the word 'recession', mostly so we could avoid saying 'depression'. As Reagan took office, Chrysler was being bailed out, and he over saw the bail out of Continental Illinois National Bank and Trust Co. This remains the "most significant bank failure resolution in the history of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation,". Is any of this sounding familiar?

By his second term, there was constant anxiety of jobs being lost to Japan, as the country was coming into its own economic boom. (Why do I feel deja vu?)

During the time of Dutch, the H. W. Bush Administration, there was a banking crisis caused by lack of regulation. Later, a recession hit causing a rash of home loses, leading to the first time since the Great Depression a large number of middle class families became homeless.

And during all this time, we were dealing with a real concern that the world could be destroyed in nuclear war.

For many of you, this is history, but for at least half of us, this is memory.

Yes, 9/11 was the biggest foreign attack of my lifetime. And yes, the Great Recession was the biggest economic threat of my lifetime. But, look at where we were are now, compared to where we went to in the past. We have learned from the past.

Today our biggest threat is terrorism, before it was nuclear annihilation. Today we have growing difficulties in getting ahead, before it was homelessness.

I write this now, because this morning, Sept 21st 2016, there was a riot is Charlotte, N.C. Fortunately none were seriously hurt. This weekend, we had a terrorist attack. Fortunately none were killed. Please remember that more than 60 died in the L.A. Riots of 1992. In 1995, 168 died in the Oklahoma City Bombing.

At this point, I would apologize for minimizing other's suffering and pain. But I'm not. We are in an environment were too many have political and economic incentive to maximize and excite. Minimizing is what we need. Calming is what we need.

And what I find most frustrating, Trump and many of his supporters are more than old enough to remember when time were worse. Still, they want us to believe these times the worst. And I really can't count them alone. There are forerunners of Trump stoking the flames through radio, TV, and the internet. Again, many of them are old enough to remember. Many of them were part of those problem. They want us to imagine exaggerated fears that were realities of the past and peddle a past free of fear.

Ironically, in my lifetime, there is only one threat different and beyond those like him: Donald J. Trump.




Friday, September 2, 2016

And Now About Racism....


What You First Must Know About Racism

Now I’m going to talk about racism.[1] This certainly won’t be the only time, but for now, I can start with an important point, what may be the most important point. Ready? Here it is:
If you are vulnerable to racism, you worry less about the racist. You worry about all the others that ignore him.
When you find you have to worry about racism, you soon realize your biggest threat is not the country turning against you. It’s that one racist in the right place that goes unnoticed. That one teacher that gives you a lower grade than you deserve, just enough to change what college you go to. That person in HR that throws away your resume because they don’t like your last name. That landlord that won’t let you move to a better neighborhood. That one person in authority that decides your kind is always guilty of something. The one juror that decides your fate before the trial has begins. The politician that finds he can get a few more votes vilifying you.

In every one of those cases, you know that if that one person was exposed and not tolerated, you would be safe. Unfortunately, you know that more likely, as long as they are careful, no one will stop them. When a racist stands up and confronts you, you can deal with him just like anyone who confronts you. But that rarely happens (at least these days). Instead, he operates under the shadow of rationalizations and innuendos. And because of this, most of the time you find yourself having to prove the “intent” of another person, which is rarely possible.

The only one who can truly stop a racist is those closest to him.

So there it is. You learn that your fate is not in the hands of the racist but everyone that lets him operate unchecked

The important point here is that this is not about hate, decency, or even good and evil. Someone can be the kindest and non-racist person in the world, but if you know they will not stand up to a racist friend, then you are not safe with that person. You may like them. You may respect them, but you cannot trust them.

How could you trust someone knowing that if having to choose between you and the racist that hates you, they would choose the racist?

Now I realize that asking you to stand up to a coworker, friend, relative, or worse yet boss can be a lot to ask. I have not always lived to that standard and would not ask you to, But it does not take much. Just once in a while. If we all did at least that, racism could not grow. It just takes one person to stand up when it matters.

And it’s not too much to ask that you stand against racism when you vote.

We can’t just ask our leaders to not be racist, they have to be ready to take action against it. I know you think racism is wrong, so why would you not ask your candidate to stand up to a racist. That’s just being a leader.

Fortunately, we live in a time where such leaders are not hard to find. Here’s what one looks like.



Here's again what it looks like.



And let us remember the George W. Bush lead us away from bigotry and racism in the midst of 9/11.


Here's what it doesn't look like.


Now I know he later renounced David Duke and made the lame excuse that "he didn't hear the question". But what about this?



And this?


Even as President, his first response it to talk about himself and conflate racism with other issues.




Now, I know many of you will say he has renounced this as well, but President Trump has never renounced racism when he was first asked. He always took at least three times before he would make even the most anodyne statement. Compare this to the force and voice he so willing to show on other issues.

And I'm not even going into President Trump's own racist remarks and the role he has played (yet). A president is supposed to lead us away from racism not towards it. To do, otherwise, is cowardice pure and simple. President Trump is either too much a coward to tell what he really thinks, or he is too much a coward to tell a bigot he is wrong. Either way, he is a coward, and why would we want a coward for a president.

Friday, July 29, 2016

So Why Am I Here Today?


I bet you've thought about starting blog. (If you have already, well good for you. I'm not talking to you yet.) As you imagined the blog you would write, you also found reasons to write it later. There's always tomorrow to make the first post right. Since the day I heard the word 'blog', the same happened for me.

I would wake up, my mind racing with fresh thoughts. As I drank my coffee, the caffeine would untangle neurons, and those thoughts would hone into full mental pontification. I would begin a blog. My words will be so creative and insightful, they'll shudder through the internet, spread only by the force of their eloquence. Followers will begin to whisper. “Who is this Gadfly?” I'll appear on the Tonight Show....

Anyway, you get the point.

Of course such thoughts always work out better in coffee stimulated daydreams, than they do in life. A blog is work. You can always daydream now and start tomorrow.

So what changed?

Well, events are happening, unlike none I have seen in my life. The times deserve my shouting whispers to vainly attempt to be heard. I know I join multitudes who have the same shouting whispers, and as corny as it is to say: 'Now is not the time to be silent'.

I am of course talking about the possibility of a Trump presidency.

Ironically, I just told you that this is not why I am here. I just said, I'm not here to change minds or go on some agenda. Now, you can see, I am going to rant like a zealot about the end of the world, fire falling from the sky, cats living with dogs...

Well, maybe not that bad. But still bad. Bad enough for me to engage in some short term hypocrisy, and yes, even start a blog and send some tweets.

In my next post (maybe a few), I will attempt to explain why Trump is different. I hope to do so in a reasoned way without relying on knee jerk reactions, overused rhetoric, and amateur psychology.

And then, I will get back to what I hoped this blog would be when I first daydreamed about it.

But for now, the danger of Trump does require us to speak out without hesitation or doubt. (Besides, I have so many Trump jokes.)

Why Am I Here?

First of all, my priority is not to change anyone's mind (though it would be nice), I'd rather you have a deeply thought opinion that I disagree with, than a shallow one I do. Not that you won't hear my overblown opinions sometimes (OK, you'll hear it a lot), but that's not my goal. Instead, I'd like to share ideas that can inspire us to think clearer. and let you shape your ideas as you wish.

So, why should you listen to me? I don't have a good answer to that just a promise. I can say that any writing I put here will not be some rant or zealot evangelizing. What I give you will be as reasoned as best I can, and with the intention of enriching your life, even if in a small way. (Oh, and I'll try to slip in some jokes when I can.)