Time To Fess Up. Is Trump Hitler Or Not?
Let’s
be clear. Trump is not Hitler. Hitler
had better hair and larger hands. I also suspect the furor had a
better sense of interior deign.
Of course, those small details has not stopped us from making
other comparison, and feeling concern about them, including myself. I’ve
been laying he groundwork for a while, so let’s finally ask the
question: Is the Trump Candidacy dangerous to our democracy? (Well,
it took long enough.)
In
The
Repeal of Godwin's Law I discussed whether we should even asked
that question. Part of the problem is that accusing a politician of
acting like the H-word has become standard rhetoric. So, while it is
appropriate to ask that question (and sometimes desperately
necessary), we do need to show why this case is different.
In
Call
Him Hitler But Let's Be Fair About It, I tried to setup some
basic ground rules. If I am successful, we can talk about this
without just going into rants or hyperbole. (But I so want to rant)
It does matter how we phrase the question, and as I pointed out this
is really an examination of his campaign and not him. Hence, I refer
to the ‘Trump Candidacy’ instead of ‘Donald J. Trump’.
So, I did my research. Read up on leaders that did become the
H-word. (Okay I did some internet searches.) Thought about it.
Couldn’t sleep. Drank a lot. And finally came to a conclusion.
Trump Candidacy is NOT a danger to our democracy, YET.
Didn’t see that one coming. Did you?
I bet you’re saying right now, “Wait, you’ve been writing
posts about this for almost a month and now you say he’s not
Hitler? Why have you been wasting our time with this.”
Hey, I’m as surprised as you. Believe it not, I thought it’d
come out differently. I tried, I really tried, but I said I would do
this objectively and that’s where it led.
Was I right to be concerned? Darn tootin. Should you have been
concerned? Darn rootin tootin. Should we remained concerned? Double
Darn rootin tootin.
So, here was my process.
When I started to write this post, I thought I would examine
specific traits of the how the Trump Campaign mirrored the infamous
figures (Ceasar, Napoleon,
Hitler, Mussolini, Simmon Cowell, that guy who hosts Iron Chef. You
know, people like that.). In “The Repeal of Godwin’s Law”, I referenced three.
-
Scapegoating
-
Appealing to resentments
-
Creating fanatical followers by manipulating group identity
I also found this article,
Donald
Trump wasn’t a textbook demagogue. Until now., which gives
four.
-
Posturing as a common man
-
Triggering powerful emotions
-
Manipulating those powerful emotions for political benefit
-
Threatening to break established principles of governance
I bet you can find a bunch of others, and what I realized after
reading a couple, I’m not that smart. Books have been written on
what makes someone an H-word (or demagogue, or autocrat, or dictator,
just go on and insert your favorite term). So just go on and read one
of those. I’m too lazy to do all that work. (Besides do you really
want to read 100 blogs on Trump = Hitler).
So,
l took a different tact. As I’ve written before, the problem with
these checklists is that a lot of politicians have used these tactics
to some extent. Granted that the Trump Candidacy uses them as if
Mein
Kampf
was a campaign textbook. But, comparing the Trump Candidacy to one of
these checklist puts us in the position of proving “how much is too
much”.
Instead,
I assumed that the checklist from other articles and books has been
met. (If you don’t like that, well read one and come back to me.)
We are assuming that the Trump Candidacy is demagogic, but, what more
is needed. I came up three.
1. Could be elected
Now I don’t think he has a good chance to win, about 30% (which
tracks well with such projections as
FiveThirtyEight)
[1]
However, if you went into surgery with on a 70% survival rate, you
would be seriously worried the night before. You certainly would not
elect to have that surgery unless it was life and death.
2. Accountable to Political Norms
I covered this in
That
Orange Guy Defies Conventions and pointed out how being a
conventional politician acts as a safety measure.
For awhile now, the Republican party has been hoping he will “come
around”. In other words, hold himself accountable to political
norms. How has that worked out for you Rience? Nor has bad press
stopped him. The Trump Candidacy’s latest response has been the
Popeye Strategy (I am what I am). So, if you thought he was defying
political norms before, than he’s basically promising to continue.
[2]
3. Fanatical Followers
And here is where we fall short.
In the end, it does not depend on Trump. It depends on Trump
supporters. A dictator cannot rule alone, and unless he has followers
that are willing to go to extreme measures, he’s really just a
ranting orange person.
In my last post,
Trump’s
My Man, I asked if Trump supporters were fanatical. I took a
stance and concluded a solid “I don’t know”. (Yeah, I’m a
wuss).
Certainly, many aspects of Trump’s support are concerning. The
fact that his supporters seemed more motivated by their faith in him,
rather than a set of ideas. That they respond to demagogic rhetoric.
And so on.
In truth, however, his supporters have behaved well within the
bounds of the democratic process. Their arguments my not have the
sophistication of a Sunday morning talk show, but that’s the
points. A lot of people have been left out in our politics, and maybe
some of our overly sophisticated idea are to blame.
So, it’s up to all you Trump supporters
[3]
out there, because everyday your leader is pushing closer and closer
to the line. One day he’s going to cross it. Maybe he’ll suggest
we need a new form of government. He’s already suggesting our
election is rigged. Maybe he’ll suggest violence. He’s already
come close to that.
The question to you Trump supporters is, when he does, what will
you do? Trump is not a danger to our democracy, YET. You Trump
supporters are the YET.
As for me, I haven’t bought a ticket to Canada so far, but I am
packing a “bug-out bag”.
[4]