Showing posts with label Is Trump Hitler?. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Is Trump Hitler?. Show all posts

Friday, October 14, 2016

Echoes of Hitler

Trump's Angriest Speech

Yes, I'm back on the Hitler thing again. But, this time, Hitler is not a stand in. I'm actually talking about the little guy with the weird mustache. And no, I'm not about to declare the Yet in Trump is Not Hitler, Yet. I'm not sounding the alarm. But Trump's last speech was disturbing in a way that needs to be pointed out.

It was billed as Trump's most angriest speech yet, which almost sounded like a joke. I mean come on, how could he get any angrier. As a matter of fact, it really was. The anger was understandable. His chances for President are collapsing, and now he's facing 10 allegations of sexual assault and harassment. He's having a tough time. I understand. I have no empathy or sympathy, but I can understand. However, where his anger went started to echo Hitler. (No, this is not a metaphor.)

First some history. As you probably all ready know, Hitler was a war hero of World War I and was fanatically patriotic to Germany[1]. Him and a lot of soldiers like him were devastated by Germany's loss, especially up until then they had been told, and believed, Germany was winning. They needed an answer, and it came in the form of a conspiracy theory, the Stab-in-the Back myth. The myth blamed Germany's defeat on domestic elements or what became known as the "November Criminals" (politicians, communists, and others including, of course, Jews). As is no surprise, Hitler became a staunch proponent of the Stab-in-the-Back myth.

With Hitler's rise in politics, the writing of Mein Kampf , and later speeches, the idea that Germany was being undermined by 'secret forces' formed. Included were international elements, what he called Internationalism. He referred to these in his speeches as 'international Stock Exchange', 'international supra-State Finance', and most famously the 'international clique'[2].





So, you can see why I felt a chill up my spine when I heard this.[3]
“Hillary Clinton meets in secret with international banks to plot the destruction of US sovereignty in order to enrich these global financial powers, her special interest friends, and her donors.”
and this
“This election will determine whether we’re a free nation, or whether we have only an illusion democracy but in are in fact controlled by a small handful of special global interests rigging the system, and our system is rigged.”
Again, I'm not banging the alarm bells. This is still not the Yet. However, as I keep reminding you, Trump is a meteor that could destroy civilization. Even if it only has a 1% chance to hit, that's enough reason to keep your telescopes pointed at the sky.


Friday, August 19, 2016

Trump Is Not Hitler, Yet.

Time To Fess Up. Is Trump Hitler Or Not?

Trump uses Mein Kampf as a campaign textbook

Let’s be clear. Trump is not Hitler. Hitler had better hair and larger hands. I also suspect the furor had a better sense of interior deign.

Of course, those small details has not stopped us from making other comparison, and feeling concern about them, including myself. I’ve been laying he groundwork for a while, so let’s finally ask the question: Is the Trump Candidacy dangerous to our democracy? (Well, it took long enough.)

In The Repeal of Godwin's Law I discussed whether we should even asked that question. Part of the problem is that accusing a politician of acting like the H-word has become standard rhetoric. So, while it is appropriate to ask that question (and sometimes desperately necessary), we do need to show why this case is different.

In Call Him Hitler But Let's Be Fair About It, I tried to setup some basic ground rules. If I am successful, we can talk about this without just going into rants or hyperbole. (But I so want to rant) It does matter how we phrase the question, and as I pointed out this is really an examination of his campaign and not him. Hence, I refer to the ‘Trump Candidacy’ instead of ‘Donald J. Trump’.

So, I did my research. Read up on leaders that did become the H-word. (Okay I did some internet searches.) Thought about it. Couldn’t sleep. Drank a lot. And finally came to a conclusion.
Trump Candidacy is NOT a danger to our democracy, YET.
Didn’t see that one coming. Did you?

I bet you’re saying right now, “Wait, you’ve been writing posts about this for almost a month and now you say he’s not Hitler? Why have you been wasting our time with this.”

Hey, I’m as surprised as you. Believe it not, I thought it’d come out differently. I tried, I really tried, but I said I would do this objectively and that’s where it led.

Was I right to be concerned? Darn tootin. Should you have been concerned? Darn rootin tootin. Should we remained concerned? Double Darn rootin tootin.

So, here was my process.

When I started to write this post, I thought I would examine specific traits of the how the Trump Campaign mirrored the infamous figures (Ceasar, Napoleon, Hitler, Mussolini, Simmon Cowell, that guy who hosts Iron Chef. You know, people like that.). In “The Repeal of Godwin’s Law”, I referenced three.
  1. Scapegoating
  2. Appealing to resentments
  3. Creating fanatical followers by manipulating group identity
I also found this article, Donald Trump wasn’t a textbook demagogue. Until now., which gives four.
  1. Posturing as a common man
  2. Triggering powerful emotions
  3. Manipulating those powerful emotions for political benefit
  4. Threatening to break established principles of governance
I bet you can find a bunch of others, and what I realized after reading a couple, I’m not that smart. Books have been written on what makes someone an H-word (or demagogue, or autocrat, or dictator, just go on and insert your favorite term). So just go on and read one of those. I’m too lazy to do all that work. (Besides do you really want to read 100 blogs on Trump = Hitler).

So, l took a different tact. As I’ve written before, the problem with these checklists is that a lot of politicians have used these tactics to some extent. Granted that the Trump Candidacy uses them as if Mein Kampf was a campaign textbook. But, comparing the Trump Candidacy to one of these checklist puts us in the position of proving “how much is too much”.

Instead, I assumed that the checklist from other articles and books has been met. (If you don’t like that, well read one and come back to me.) We are assuming that the Trump Candidacy is demagogic, but, what more is needed. I came up three.

1. Could be elected

Now I don’t think he has a good chance to win, about 30% (which tracks well with such projections as FiveThirtyEight)[1] However, if you went into surgery with on a 70% survival rate, you would be seriously worried the night before. You certainly would not elect to have that surgery unless it was life and death.

2. Accountable to Political Norms

I covered this in That Orange Guy Defies Conventions and pointed out how being a conventional politician acts as a safety measure.

For awhile now, the Republican party has been hoping he will “come around”. In other words, hold himself accountable to political norms. How has that worked out for you Rience? Nor has bad press stopped him. The Trump Candidacy’s latest response has been the Popeye Strategy (I am what I am). So, if you thought he was defying political norms before, than he’s basically promising to continue.[2]

3. Fanatical Followers

And here is where we fall short.

In the end, it does not depend on Trump. It depends on Trump supporters. A dictator cannot rule alone, and unless he has followers that are willing to go to extreme measures, he’s really just a ranting orange person.

In my last post, Trump’s My Man, I asked if Trump supporters were fanatical. I took a stance and concluded a solid “I don’t know”. (Yeah, I’m a wuss).

Certainly, many aspects of Trump’s support are concerning. The fact that his supporters seemed more motivated by their faith in him, rather than a set of ideas. That they respond to demagogic rhetoric. And so on.

In truth, however, his supporters have behaved well within the bounds of the democratic process. Their arguments my not have the sophistication of a Sunday morning talk show, but that’s the points. A lot of people have been left out in our politics, and maybe some of our overly sophisticated idea are to blame.

So, it’s up to all you Trump supporters[3] out there, because everyday your leader is pushing closer and closer to the line. One day he’s going to cross it. Maybe he’ll suggest we need a new form of government. He’s already suggesting our election is rigged. Maybe he’ll suggest violence. He’s already come close to that.

The question to you Trump supporters is, when he does, what will you do? Trump is not a danger to our democracy, YET. You Trump supporters are the YET.

As for me, I haven’t bought a ticket to Canada so far, but I am packing a “bug-out bag”.[4]

Tuesday, August 16, 2016

Trump's My Man

Is It Fair To Call Trump Supporters Fanatical?


Trump once said, “I could shoot somebody and I wouldn’t lose voters”.[1] Now before any Trump supporters get mad at me for calling them fanatical, I didn’t. Your candidate did. Any other candidate would have lost their primary (or at least had to apologize). For Trump, many just laughed.

Now, I realize anyone would object to being painted as fanatical, and we have a lot of people with real frustrations and problems that only the Trump Candidacy seems willing to address. I get it. I really do. In fact, I feel some of it.

Now if you support Trump and have read this far, you are not a fanatic. As it is, also, unfair to me to label any one block of people in such a way. So, let me try to be more thoughtful here.

If you don’t see him as the threat, you can reasonably vote for Trump. Perhaps you just don’t like Hillary. If you are sufficiently concerned about the direction of the country, in particular foreign policy and trade, and you don’t see an issue with his approach to terrorism and immigration, then there is no fanaticism either.

Sure Trump has rallies. Obama had rallies. Sure Trump has supporters that argue past what seem obvious criticism. But, they can easily show this happening with past and current candidates. Again what is different?

Trump supporters have not been violent or even exceptionally vocal. They’ve just had fun at rallies.

Consider that when Goldwater and Perot ran they had a lot of specific. (For Perot, a lot of charts. A whole lot of charts). You could ask someone why they were voting Goldwater or Perot and get specifics. (Often too much specifics). Ted Cruz’s supporters are definitely passionate. But, they follow him because of his proven adherence to Conservative Principles.

So does the Trump Candidacy have supporters that see him as we would any candidate, offering a plan of government, or are they[2] blindly inspired by him. The numbers matter too, because every candidate has some fanatics in their ranks, just not enough to raise concern.

I’m not sure we can know until after the election. We have to see how support is affected when Trump disappoints (as in changes policies to other than promised or loses the election). Voters will turn away. Fanatics will stay.

However, recently there is a new twist.

When the Trump Candidacy starts saying “if I [Trump] lose, it’s because the election was rigged.”[3], this attacks the legitimacy of our democracy. In other words, this is the rationale of revolution. Now, me saying that is inflammatory. More likely this is just a way for Trump to preserve his ego and start a television network. But, the legitimacy argument stays out there, and intentionally or not, the movement can grow where they only see Trump (or his successor) as legitimate. Even if this takes a while, remember there is Eric Trump.

If you are a Trump supporter and have gotten this far, let me take the opportunity to make a plea to you. Don’t fall for this.

For the last 16 years (at least) the Republican party has been successful at getting what they want in trade and tax cuts, but have failed in any of the social goals promised. While the Democratic party has made offers to help, they have also largely failed you. I would be angry too. But take a moment and think back. Think back to when you were excited about Bush, Romney or even Obama. Does it feel any different than it does with Trump?

Now he’s suggesting that any loss is not his fault. You know what’s next right? Watch his TV network. Buy his book. Give him money. Give him power. Now what is more likely? A grand conspiracy is afoot by the same institutions you know are incompetent, or that Trump is playing you and covering for his failure?

Only a fanatic would fall for that?

Thursday, August 11, 2016

That Orange Guy Defies Convention

Trump's Unconventional Style Means

We Have to Be More Careful

The Gadfly explains how an unconventional candidate can be a threat to democracy.

P. J. O’Rourke said it best. “She's [Hillary Clinton] wrong about absolutely everything, but she's wrong within normal parameters."

If you've read The Repeal of Godwin's Law and Call Him Hitler But Let's Be Fair About It, you know that I've been building to see if the Trump Candidacy is a threat to our democracy. His words are easily argued as demagogic (and I certainly will in another post), but reasoning on that line has proved tricky. Other politicians have been demagogic only not with the same intensity. There has to be more than that.

What is it that makes the Trump Candidacy feel so different? And by different I mean scary. Maybe it is what makes him so appealing, his unconventionality.

Trump supporters keep on asking why he has to answer questions like, “Do you disavow the KKK”, “Do you rule out interment camps”, etc. Other candidates don't. Well, he's proposed ideas like “banning Muslims” or blatantly describes a group as “criminals and rapists”, If another candidate did, than yeah. They get asked questions like that.

But perhaps another reason is that before the Trump Candidacy, presidential candidates were more conventional, and that made them accountable.

What many find disturbing (including myself) is that there seems no restraint on  the Trump Candidacy's speech or proposals. If another candidate had said any of the statements in question, their own party would discourage such behavior. And that candidate WOULD LISTEN. He (and she) needed his party. He needed the good will of donors, and he needed the support of activist. Or at least there was a history of services, government or military, where we saw such restraints.

But the Trump Candidacy brags about not being restrained or even willing to self-impose their own. That is part of the campaign rationale. No allegiance to a corrupt party. Not beholden to donors. Not belonging to special interests. And not, being corrupted by years of being a politician.

However, that means if the Trump Candidacy should win, what would stop such behavior in the White House? Yeah, there’s the Congress and the Supreme Court, but do we really want it to go that far. Saying 'We elected a dictator, but that’s OK. We can spend the next four years curbing him.' is not a comfort.

Now, this would be an issue with any outsider candidates. You could ask why there were no concerns about Ross Perot or even Ted Cruz. (Well, we had many concerns about them, but not the racist H-word thing. Well, maybe about Cruz). But these candidates showed restraints in other ways. They were loyal to ideologies and measures of decorum. 

Given that we are a democracy, expecting parties, donors, and activists to restrain a politician is well, undemocratic. The voters should be to who the Trump Candidacy is accountable. And given that the only time his behavior has changed is in response to low poll ratings, that seems his only limit.

But hey, that’s why I’m writing this. I'm talking to you, the voter. The Trump Candidacy is suppose to be earning our vote, and doing so humbly. He should act as if we are the boss, because we are the boss.

Sure a candidate can defy the conventions of his party, his donors, and ideologies. However, he can't defy our conventions. Being unconventional is cool, but that shifts all the responsibility to us. This is the time to be more skeptical and demand more restraint, not settle for less.

The point is that an unconventional and independent candidate is fine, but those conventions and allegiances are safeguards against bad behavior. Without those safeguards, that candidate needs to be examined more closely and held to a higher standard.

Should the press ask him more questions than the other candidate? Yes.
Should we have more specifics on his policy? Yes.
Do we get to criticize him more when he missteps? Yes.

Not only should we do this, we must do this. His unconventionality gives us no other choice.

And if the Trump Candidacy refuses, WE DON'T ELECT HIM. No restraints means no vote. Otherwise, as president, he has no reason to act differently, nor do politicians afterward.

Now it is up to us, because we are all that is left.

Friday, August 5, 2016

Call Him Hitler But Let's Be Fair About It

An Objective Way To Ask If Trump Could Be Hitler

Life often gives us warnings when we are headed on the wrong course. They're subtle. They're quiet. There easy to miss, but when you look back you realize that if you had paid attention to that moment, your life would have not taken that awful turn.

I'm talking about Trump, of course.

Oh come on, you knew I was going there, It's not like I'm the only one. Go search on "Trump Hitler". Even those trying to say he's not Hitler are arguing that he is more like Mussolini or Silvio Berlusconi. (And that's just the Washington Post).

The problem is that if you searched on "Obama Hitler" or "Bush Hitler", you would find a lot of links too. Comparing to Hitler is sooo yesterday.

So how do I talk about him without sounding like a raving, well, blogger?

In my last blog, The Repeal of Godwin's Law, I argued that, while most of the time comparing a politician to Hitler was wrong, there are rare times when the comparison is necessary.

So, given we are at such a time, are we in danger of Trump being the new Hitler? (Yeah, that sounded like a raving blogger).

So, let's do something a little different. Let's have some ground rules.

First of all, 'Trump is Hitler' is incorrect. No one is suggesting that Trump is trying to resurrect the Third Reich. What I really mean is:
Could the Trump Candidacy endanger the US Democracy?
And there's my second ground rule. This is not about Trump. This is about his candidacy. As far as I know Donald J. Trump is a descent and generous man. There is even evidence to this. This is about the way he has chosen to run for the presidency. So, from now, that exactly how I'll refer to it: the Trump Candidacy. (I'm still making jokes about him, however).

And by extension of these two rules, we are not talking about character, temperament, or policy. That's all part of the standard election debates. The question is whether this election is different. (I mean other than it looks like the start of a WWE match).

My third ground rule is that the Trump Candidacy is an indication of the Trump Government. (OK this is more a point, but it is relevant). Yes, the Trump Government could be totally different, but if that's the case, then this is all just one big con job. (Wait a minute!)

OK, my final ground rule. (We'll more of a clarification.) I mean endanger our democracy, not take over. It's enough that a soft coup is tried, whether bloody or not. Even a constitutional crisis, impeachment, or needing to be saved by Jack Bauer is enough reason to raise alarms.

Got all that? Yeah, it was a lot. But we're trying to be fair and thorough here. What do you think this is? Twitter?

But, this did go on a bit, so I'll just have to continue in my next post. There, I'll talk about how the H-word applies (if at all) to the Trump Candidacy.

Sunday, July 31, 2016

The Repeal of Godwin’s Law

The Gadfly Scholar explains why comparisons to Hitler can be more than rhetorics.

Since the first election I can remember, and probably through all American history (perhaps all of history), we have heard each election talk as if no other election was as importance as this.

From the podium, someone in a blue suit and red tie would eventually say. “This time is special….. If the other side wins, life in America will irrecoverably changed to tyranny….. The Earth will crack. Demons will usher in the End of Times….. And oh, be sure to vote for me.”

That’s how it ends. Always with “vote for me”. We have become cynical of such language, and correctly conclude that it is just part of politics. Oh sure, some are swayed into the urgency of the moment, and do what such speeches intend. We do more than vote. We evangelize. (Some of us even write blogs.)

And then, whoever, wins we just move on to the next election, and yes often there is change, sometimes bad sometimes good. Sometimes it look bad and turns out good, and the other way. But, rarely, if ever, elections change as much as the campaign predict.

We are, of course, talking about hyperbole.

Now let me tell you about World War II.

To be old enough to remember WW II, you would be in your 80's, so most of us don’t remember it. But, many of us remember having parents and grandparents who lived it. For someone, living through WW II very little could compare. Imagine how you felt the day of 9/11. Now imagine that going on for over four years.

For those of us, who grew up in its historical shadow, we saw the way it shaped our culture and politics. In particular, we saw an overwhelming motive behind the previous generation.
To never let a world war happen again.
Every president from Eisenhower to George H. W. Bush served in the WW II. Many of them saw combat, and three won medals.[1] For president informed by that experience, part of their every foreign policy was to never have a WW III.

It is the reason we have the United Nations and NATO. It was stated by George H. W. Bush as a reason for the 1st Iraq War, then by Bill Clinton for the US to be involved in the Bosnian Civil War. And for the rest of us not in the military or juggling foreign policy, we had another mission, for even those born after WWII.
To never let there be another Hitler (or Mussolini).
I know. I know. We are not suppose to talk about him any more. Nazi are only to be referred to in video games and action movies. There was, however, a reason he is so often brought up. Comparison of Hitler is not just a rhetorical trick. His rise to power represents an institutional fear born from one of the most evil regimes in modern history.

The villains of WW II in Europe did not rise in a bloody coup.[2] They were not the descendants of monarchs. They did not fall from space and take over using mind control rays They were elected.

This is the reason he is referred to, so much. Historians, psychologists, sociologist, and other scholars have since then studied his rise to power. Artist, especially those that lived thru that time, routinely allude to him, giving us a template of how such a man can usurp a democracy. And we now have a thorough understanding of his tactics.

And there’s the problem. You see Hitler’s tactics weren’t that special. They were tried and true political tactics that existed long before the 1930's. Scapegoating to shift blame, appealing to resentments, invoking fear of the other, using group identity to create fanatical followers are not new. They have been and still are part of politics. You can even see them used by corporations, in advertising, and, if you look, in your own job. The autocrats of WW II only did it to a much much larger degree, and used them to lead their countries to disastrous ends.

Now history is more complicated than I describe. People are much more complicated than I describe. There were also many historical events that contributed. And, what we call fascist does not strictly adhere to Fascism. But that has been rarely the point.

Autocrats have risen to power in other circumstances than those leading to WW II, and arguing the cause and effect are beyond what we could discuss here by a lack of scope and, frankly, my lack of expertise. Right now, though, that they happen is enough to be concerned.

Falling to communism, plutocracy, or any other autocracy would mean the end of democracy just as much as fascism. All could be the result of a Hitler-like politician. Hitler is just a stand in for all these threats.

So, yes, references to Hitler are overused. And, yes, we too often see Hitler at the smallest resemblance. I am admitting to all that. Given that our democracy is still intact, we have been overreacting in our fear of WW III. Hitler so far has just been hyperbole.

The point here is that there is a reason to fear the rise of the autocrat. The threat may have the likelihood of a meteor hitting the Earth, but one day a meteor will hit the Earth. Yes, the smart bet is that today the meteor will not. However, one day we will have to listen to that lone astronomer, even when so many in the past have been wrong.

So, here’s the problem. When you are warned that the next president could be a Hitler, you would be smart to ignore it. But, one day, the threat will be real. What rational argument would be enough to look beyond the false alarm? What “science” would we need?

We now have a presidential candidate that has used more Hitler-like tactics than I have seen in my lifetime. (And I’m old enough to remember Nixon.) He is also the first one since WW II[3]  to get this close to the presidency. Is now the time we should invoke Hitler, and if not when?