Showing posts with label Election 2016. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Election 2016. Show all posts

Monday, November 7, 2016

Election 2016 Update 11-07

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 30% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

The Horse Race

Numbers are moving fast and in a pro-Clinton direction (whew). As of now.

Trump Needs to Take: NH, NV, NC, FL

But NV, NC and FL are on the razors edge. As of this morning these were slight 'wins' for Trump.

Trump's Hail Mary

Trump is letting the obvious states go on auto-pilot hoping they just win "on their own". Instead, he is focusing on the 'rust belt': MN, MI, WI, and PA. The reason is he may have no other choice. There's some rumbling that he's already lost NV in the early vote. (I tend to agree). If so, NH is not going to help, and he needs to take a bigger state. These are his best chances.

The Big Mo

Some pundits like to stress 'mo' or momentum. Up until now, Trump had it, but as of the morning there was the most subtle shift back to Clinton to a +3. But, we are about to go into a statistical 'dark zone'. It's like those old movies where the hero and the villain fall into the water, and we're waiting to see who comes up.

My Numbers

So, I looked at them and they've held so far. I'm not changing them except for a 1% or so. There are ways I could do better, but I'm just going to declare myself a genius for now and leave them alone. They don't mean much now but the take away is:
  • Trump's ceiling is 46% and Clinton's is 50%
  • Votes to Jill Stein are taken from Clinton
  • Votes to Gary Johnson are mostly taken from Trump

What to Watch Tomorrow Night

If you're like me, I'm watching with a bottle of whisky and a paper bag for when I hyperventilate. So, here's what to watch for to know when you can relax (a little).

Watch NH and NC. These states are on the East Coast and close at 7 and 7:30 PM. With luck we can get some assurance by 9 PM EST. If Trump looses NH or NC, his path to 270 becomes unlikely. Not impossible, but enough that I can put the paper bag down.

If he loses FL, it's basically over for Trump, but I have a feeling FL won't have results until late in the night. On the other hand, it is a East Coast state with early voting, so it could, also, make the night shorter. If any unexpected red state, like GA flip to blue, he's in just as much trouble.

If an unexpected blue states, like those in the rust belt, flip red, than we are in for a long night. I might have to just hide under my covers in the fetal position for the rest of the night.

If you want to watch with more detail, including which counties to monitor, here's a nifty link.

Of course, there is always a chance Trump could win until all the votes have been counted, so you can relax if the news is good, but don't drop your guard.

The Senate

I haven't talked much about, but that something to watch too. Right now, it's a straight 50-50 chance on which party controls the Senate. Here's the states to watch: PA, NV, NH, and MO.

Democrats need to get 3 of the 4. If you want more, here's a link.

So, What’s Next for the Ol’Gadfly

To begin with, this is my last daily update. My plan is to spend more time on non-political writing. (Yes, I do think of other things besides politics, though not much. Firsts, there’s eating, sleeping…. I know there’s more. Let me get back to you on that.) But, I do intend to continue this blog and post regularly. I’m thinking about once a week, but we’ll have to see,

Obviously what I write can depend on who wins tomorrow. If Trump wins, no I will not spend all my time writing about him. I want to give information that’s useful and not just rant. You know stuff like how to sneak out of the country, what to do if you survive a nuclear war, how to make food out of plasterboard….

But seriously, except for the occasional ‘meteor warning’ post, most of what I've planned is the same if Clinton wins. As I mentioned in my 2nd post, So Why Am I Here Today?, I’m engaging in some ‘short term hypocrisy’, so I will start by walking that back. I’ll then to go back to the more bipartisan writing I’d hope to start with. I may stay provocative (if Clinton wins) or less to avoid being sent to the gulag (if Trump wins). And no, I will not stop telling Trump jokes.

My hope is to do mostly what I call 'evergreen' posts, writings that are not connected to current events, such as 'what effect do taxes really have on the economy',  'what should be the purpose of third parties', or 'can politicians be honest'. Not to mention, adding to what I already started: coalitions, crazy ideas, and 'Many people are saying..."

If I talk abut Trump at all, I expect them to be 'Trump adjacent', not about him but the fallout and legacy of this election: 'the coming Republican Party fight', 'what we've learned from him', and 'how to watch for next Hitler'. But, don't worry. Those won't be right away. I know you're sick of him, and I have to recover from my PESD (Post Election Syndrome Disorder).

Saturday, November 5, 2016

Election 2016 Update 11-04 and 11-05

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 36% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

Last Nights Bombshell

...was a fizzle. Not that no one tried. We had:
That Beyonce wore a pantsuit is making as much noise. There is of course the non-news news that Comey has not declared all the emails duplicates.

The Horse Race

So, it is most likely to be about how each candidate is doing for the next 4 days. Looking at Real Clear Politics the polls have stabilized for the last 6 to 7 days: 46% to 48%  Clinton and 45% Trump 2-way, 45% Clinton and 43% Trump. We can think of this as Clinton has rallied her Excitables and Borings, while Trump has rallied all of his Hopeys and Trumpys. As long as this is the case, the election is all about turnout now.

As I said before, polls start to become less useful this close to the election, so I will only be using the FiveThirtyEight forecast from now on. If I see something that changes in the polls. I'll let you know,

The most important forecast number is the one I've been giving you in the 'Trump Meteor Forecast'. If we want to treat it as a poll, we can use the forecasted popular vote. (Today is 48.5% Clinton, 45.5% Trump, and 4.5% Johnson).


That's, though, to give us a value we are more familiar with. In the end, what is more important are how each state is doing. For as long as I can remember, if Clinton wins every state she is ahead in, she wins. Trump has to win all of his, and take one from her. So, I usually watch these four states: NH, NV,  NC, and FL (of course).

Clinton is currently forecasted to win NH, while Trump is only slightly above 50-50 for the rest. Of course, any of the other states could be switched, but the stats say those are the only ones where Trump has any kind of chance. I showed you a neat graphic for this in the last post, but I'll probably refer to them as this:

Trump needs to take: NH
Trump needs to win: NV,  NC, and FL

Different forecasting models could give you a slightly different list of states, of course.

Warning: Don't get to comfortable counting states. States tend to swing together. So, Trump winning FL might mean winning NV more likely. (I just made that up, but you get the point), In other words, winning 3 states is not 3 times as hard as winning one

Now, you will hear about Trump trying to win PI, MI, or WI, and Clinton trying to win AZ or OH. Maybe they know something the rest of us don't, trying to fake out the other side, defend against the other, help out senators and congressmen, etc. Trump likes to have rallies when he as to be there for another reason such as fundraising.  The point is don't let that confuse you.

Then There's the Weird Stuff

The FiveThrirtyeEight also gives the chance of crazy outcomes: recounts, deadlock. etc. The big one that needs to be point out is Trump's chance to win the Electoral College but lose the popular vote (currently 12%). This is unusually high, and Trump has a low chance to win. Therefore, if Trump wins, he has a 1 out 3 chance of it being like Bush in 2000. This means that the "democratic advantage" in the Electoral Map is not has high as most think.

The Early Vote Gets to Ignore All of This

There are currently 150 million registered voters. With an historic turnout of 60%, that's 90 million votes. Last I heard, 30 million have already voted. Given that a third have already voted does that affect the odds.

Conventional wisdom is no. The polls and forecast don't use them as a factor. In some polls, they treat early voters as likely voters and affect the forecast that way. There is some thought that since so much has happened over the last week it affected earlier votes differently. (As in those that voted before the Comey letter, than after). Conventional thought is that early voters are resolved voters making it no difference, but expect this point to be debated well after the election.

However, early voting does mean turnout, which is decisive in this election.

Thursday, November 3, 2016

Election 2016 Update 11-03

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 35% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

What a difference 1 point makes

Today Trump and Clinton poll numbers have not changed in the Real Clear Politics poll average, 45% Trump and 47% Clinton (43% and 45% 4-way). So, my current numbers are holding, but just. As is, every pro-Trump voter would have in this stat, and any rise means the numbers have to be re-evaluated. I'm reviewing them as we speak, in case that happens tomorrow.

The other question is can Clinton stay at or above 47%. Common wisdom is that Trump can't go above 46% (it would be the first time ever). However, until I can find reason, Clinton could go lower than 46% and that is scary. (However, so far her numbers have been holding. I just haven't been able to support it with any math).

2-Way vs 4-Way

I've keep referring to 2-way versus 4-way polls. (Keep your dirty jokes to yourself). Just as a reminder, 4-way polls include Third Party (Gary Johnson and Jill Stein). 2-way polls don't. You could say, I should be only referring to 4-way polls. All four will be on the ballot after all, but the expectation is that as we get closer the 4-way polls move closer to the 2-ways (which is exactly what's happening). That can give you a distorted view if you only look at the 4-way early in the race. In the FiveThirtyEight forcast models, you can see that where they forecast the popular vote.

What you may have noticed is that I use the 4-way numbers to predict the lowest candidates can go and the 2-way numbers to predict the highest. This makes sense when you think about it.

Of course now that we move closer to the end of the race, we have to look at the 4-way more. The best policy is to only use these polls as a general guide anyway.

Times running out for the polls

The numbers today go back to Oct 24th and a lot has happened then. By Election Day, these numbers will have to be too far in the past, and I'll have to rely more on forecasts and projections. Of course, there will be polls going up to the day, but I don't trust individual polls. It's too easy to pick the ones that tell you the story you want. So, then I'll be just using the polls to set some boundaries.

What's up with these 538 guys?

So,  now that we are talking forecast, you should have notice I've been using those from FiveThirtyEight. I have a good understanding as to what they are doing, they had a good performance in the last election, and most importantly they give Trump the best chance.

Basically they use state polls only (no national polls) to give each state a ranges of outcomes. Then, they run the possibilities through a computer simulation several thousand times. Of course, there's a lot more details, but that's about as much as we can go into.

If you want to follow them yourself, what you most need to know is that there are three models:

The Now-cast does not make any projections into the future. It just takes the chances of winning the states and pretends the election was today. From following the guys that make this, they have little respect for this model, and kind of wish they never included it. I just use this as if it was a tracking poll.

The Polls-only looks at the chances and project what they will be on Election Day from how the numbers are trending. (For you mathy types they basically apply a linear regression.) This is their favorite and has become the only one they talk about about. You could (and probably should) just look at this one.

The Polls-plus uses the Polls-only and adjust it with political science to include factors such as the economy, past history, approval ratings, etc. As time has gone on, they've referred to this model less and less probably because this election is looking less conventional. I have been using this one in the Trump Meteor Forecast only because it give a more pro-Trump chance.

One neat little graphic I've found useful is this one (Polls-only)



This quickly tells you what states the candidates need to win and how likely they are to win them. The darker the color the best chance for the candidate.

From here we see that Trump needs to win every red state and still has to take a state away from Clinton. His best shot is to take New Hampshire.

Clinton, on the other hand, does have to hold on to all of the blue states, but does not have to take any of Trump. Also, she has a better chance to take Nevada, Florida, or North Carolina, than Trump has of taking New Hampshire.

Polls. Polls. Polls All you want to take about is polls

Yeah, it's been a lot about the polls lately. Truth is that's what most of the news has been about. But how about some other campaign stuff.

Before the Comey letter, Clinton was going into red states and trying to help win Senate seats. Now, she gotten more "defensive". Looking at the graphic you can see why. Both candidates have made their strategy clear including telling it straight to reporters.

Clinton knows she just has to keep Trump in check. She also has a lot of prominent figures that can campaign for her: the President, the First Lady, and the Vice President. This lets her campaign go into all of the blues states to keep Trump from winning them. She has been taking advantage of the  good ground operation the campaign built. If Trump does get to even in the polls with her, then who can turnout the vote wins. That's why she working so hard to get people to early vote.

Trump only has Trump. He can only be in so many places at once. So, he has also focused on the blue states, trying to win one. He just has to hope the red states go to him on their own. Since, the best he can do is get to even, he knows it's going to be about turnout, but he has not built up a turnout operation. Instead, the focus has been "suppressing" Clinton voters. (This is actually the words the Trump campaign has used, but they've also made it clear that they mean negative advertising. Though still this has created some suspicion of more nefarious measures).

Can We Talk About Some News Here

Yeah, I know it's been all about polls and horse race. That's not just me, however. It's not that there is no news, it's that there's too much. If you do any googles, you'll see different articles about the candidate every hour or so. You almost get the feeling that the media is throwing the kitchen sink at them.

The reason is less nefarious. The journalists have been working on investigative stories for awhile now, especially about Trump. However, with only a few days left, they have to publish what they've got or just throw all their research into a drawer. So, we have been inundated with half-done investigative stories.

And tomorrow is Friday. I'm not sure why, but lately breaking stories have been happening on Friday: the Comey letter, the Grabby video, etc. So, I'm anticipating it. Here are some guesses.

  1. Comey reports that all emails were duplicates (fingers crossed).
  2. Woman claiming Trump raped her when she was 13 finally comes forward.
  3. Trumps taxes are leaked.
  4. President Obama announces that Mosul has been captured.
  5. Violence will occur from some white supremacist. Unfortunately, that already happened. Black church burned and 2 policeman killed in Iowa.
  6. The Clinton Campaign admits to having 156 volumes of opposition research on Trump. Podesta states "we have sex scandals, bribery attempts, racist statements and more. We just could not find anything worse than what Trump as already done on the campaign."
  7. Trump declares that he has secretly been in love with Rosie O'Donnell.
  8. Robert LiButtie, the mob figure, who was Trump's friend. Turns out to be Goldy Digits.
  9. Clinton and Trump tear off their mask revealing that they are Kang and Kodos from the Simpsons


Just as a heads up. I am intentionally going to be late on Friday's update just in case any of this happens,.

Wednesday, November 2, 2016

Election 2016 Update 11-02

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 32% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

Poll Watching

I'm still trying to re-evaluate how to look at the polls, just like everyone else. The problem is that when Trump reached 45% 2-way that invalidated my prediction that he would still be limited by the 1st Debate and could only go to 43%. The 45% is still within the bounds set in The Final Stretch, just barely. If Trump goes higher, then I will re-work the numbers.

For Clinton, we have the opposite situation. She's stayed above 47% 2-way since the first debate, and her 4-way numbers are even more consistent. She's stayed 45% to 46% since Oct 16th. If I have to change numbers there's a chance I can raise her floor.

Having to now factor in the Obamacare news, I would not be surprised if Clinton is gets to 1% or even tied with Trump. If that scares you, it scares me. Just to bring our heart rates down, let me say that the state by state polls are telling us a less scary story. Let's suffice to say, that's looking like Clinton 48% to Trump 45%, but there's a lot of more details, I would need to go into. (There are 50 states after all.)

I'll hopefully be able to be more definitive tomorrow.

Enough with the Emails

The FBI should be able to finish their cursory investigations before the end of the week. If they can find only duplicates, Comey should make an announcement. To do otherwise, would be criminal consider the chaos he's already made. However, that's unlikely. Even if one email needs to be evaluated, that starts a bureaucratic process that goes past the election.

Fingers crossed.

Tuesday, November 1, 2016

Election 2016 Update 11-01

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 31% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

What's Old is New Again

Would you believe. There's a chance that some voters are responding to an actually issues. On Oct 24th, the Department of Health announced a rise in premiums. You probably have heard this but not much. The news ended up 'siloed' in conservative media, and some are arguing that Trump's polls increase is mostly due to this.

Are My Numbers Wrong?

In my Oct 28th update, I set some new numbers.

39% Trumpys
4% to 6% Hopeys

43% Borings
2% to 6% Excitables

6% to 8% No-Way-No-Hows
2% to 6% Wait-n-Sees

However, Trump has had a steady raise and hit my estimated ceiling of 45%. Right now, Trump is enjoying a triple hit.
  1. A good enough performance on the 3rd Debate to encourage some Hopeys 
  2. News of higher premiums for Obamacare 
  3. The Comey notification to Congress 
The numbers are still holding, including the prediction that Clinton still leads by 2% to 3%. But, if Trump goes higher, my assumption that Trump is still defined by the 1st Debate is probably wrong. That can change everything.

Monday, October 31, 2016

Election 2016 Update 10-31

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 26% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

Update on the Techy Stuff

In my last update, I went over the technological aspects of Comey's announcement. In part, I voiced some consternation as to why some basic scanning had not been done. Today, I have an answer to that question. Remembering that the investigation up till late last week only involved Anthony Weiner, the FBI needed a new warrant to go into Huma Abedin's emails. They obtained that warrant today.

Now that they have the warrant, the FBI appears to be following steps similar to what I outlined. As per Pete Williams reporting on NBC:
“They’ll narrow them down to look at just those dating from the time Hillary Clinton was secretary of state. Then they’ll weed out any that are not about government business. Agents will use automated software to search what’s left for duplicates they’ve already found during the investigation of the Clinton e-mail server. Any that remain will be checked for classified information,” Williams reported on “Today” this morning. “Officials say there’s no way to tell how long that will take. But they say if it goes quickly, and nothing classified is found, the FBI could say so within the next few days. It largely depends on how many of the e-mails are duplicates and how many are new to the investigators.”
Abedin is also stating that she does know how the emails got there, suggesting that it may have happened through an automated process (and assuming she is telling the truth). This would be similar to what I described would happen if she had setup her email account on it. Though there are other automated process that I would need more information before ruling out.

Maybe Not Clinton

A subtle point is that none of the statements have just used the word "Clinton" . The statements have used the word "Clinton Investigation". We tend to forget that the investigation towards the private servers was not just about Clinton. It was about everyone using the servers. So, the Comey statements may only be considering Abedin as culpable. Again, another detail that should have been clarified.

This is me reading in between the lines, so remember to consider that as you form your own opinion.

Saturday, October 29, 2016

Election 2016 Update 10-28

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 21% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

Yes I Know It's Saturday

As I was writing this, news hit that FBI Directory Comey had notified congressman of potential new Clinton emails found. If you've had any contact with a human being or electronic device, you've already heard about this. Comey statement amounted to "I may have found something important, maybe not. I'll tell you later. I don't know when.". That has us all chasing our tails.

So, I wanted to let the story brew a bit.

Is the Trump Meteor Going to Hit Now?

How has Trump chances of becoming president change? The short answer is that his chances have probably risen to 30% and in an extreme case 50%. Obviously, that's all subject to what polls say that have not come out yet.

So, let's look at what numbers we have.

In a previous update I gave post new Post Labor day numbers.
39% Trumpys
4% to 6% Hopeys

43% Borings
2% to 6% Excitables

6% to 8% No-Way-No-Hows
2% to 6% Wait-n-Sees

Now nothing this bad has happened to Clinton since Labor Day, so can we still say her 43% base still holds or do we need to go back her pre-Labor Day of 39%? I believe we can still stay with the 43% for two reasons. One, the No-Way-No-Hows (Johanson and Sten voters) has been around 7% lately, so attitudes towards Third Parties definitely changed. Two, the numbers were formed by Trump's horrible performance from the 1st Debate. Comey did not suddenly prove Trump is now 'temperamentally fit'.

The news analysts are saying this will not take votes away from Clinton, but would add votes to Trump. This translates to Clinton being ahead by 2% to 3% instead of 5% to 6%. I would agree with this, but I'd like to back it up with more math.

If we assume that No-Way-No-Hows are going to be 6% and Trump can't beat a post-Debate high of 43%, the Clinton starts with 43%, leaving 6% of Excitables/Wait-n-Sees for her. Her maintaining 2% to 3% lead looks quick likely with those numbers. That coincides with where the race was Oct 2 to Oct 3, which is 30% in the FiveThirtyEight Nowcast.

Now, if there are the Shy Trump voters mentioned in When Can We Say Trump Will Not Be President? and/or more bad news for Clinton, Trump could pull even, and thus 50%.

Here's the good news. Comey provided such vague information, the news cannot talk about about this for 10 days. If Comey provides more details, the news is more likely good (all were duplicates, etc.) for Clinton, because the bad outcomes (ground to reconsider prosecution, etc.) take longer to reach. Clinton also has all the tactical advantages if the race goes to turnout, and over 12 million have already voted.

Tech Talk

I'm not going to go into all the details of the story because you can get that from all the professional news sources. However, fortunate for you, I understand the technology well, and here I can add.

Following some bread crumb, I can speculate with some confidence that the Clinton servers were using Microsoft Exchange Server. That's important because different email software stores emails differently. In all cases, emails are stored on the server. With Microsoft Exchange Server the emails can potentially be stored in two other devices: the one that received the email and the one that sent it. So, now we can see why Huma Abedin laptop becomes part of the investigation.

The next thing to know is how emails get deleted. When Office 'deletes' an email, it archives it instead, in case you want the email back and technical reasons we don't care about. But the archived emails are marked as what can be removed if you need more space on your hard drive. Then, the OS deletes the emails.

However, when an OS deletes a file, it does not delete the data. It removes knowledge of where the file is on the hard drive. You can think of it as more the OS 'forgets' the file. Now in time, that hard drive location will be re-used, but until then you can recover the deleted files with special software and some work. The company managing the servers did more. They used a software, BeachBit that overwrite those location to prevent them from being recovered.

My guess is that the FBI used a special technique that read trace magnetic field off the hard drive to read 'bleached' data. (Yep, that's some super spy type stuff there.) But, the technique cannot 100% restore the data. The FBI was left with only what Clinton had handed over, what had been sent to/from others, and the fragments they had recovered. They can never be sure they got every email.

It's a good bet, however, Abedin unlikely went to such extraordinary measures. So, you can see why there would be some hope that the FBI could find emails they had not seen before. But, any of these emails would have been duplicated on the server, and in all likelihood, the FBI has already seen them.

Now lets talk about how email gets sent. When you send an email, until it reaches the recipient, anyone with the technology to 'listen' can read it. Doing so is hard and the email is sent in mixed pieces so it's not as bad as it sounds. You can think of it as talking to someone in a crowded room where everyone is talking loudly. Someone could be listening in, but they're more likely only to hear fragments of your conversation. When you're worried about state secrets, however, that can be enough.

The only way to thwart easedropping is to encrypt the emails as they are sent. This though requires coordination between the software the sender and receiver are using. Even then, if a hacker can get into the device he can 'infect' it with software that reads the emails before and after they are secured.

This is where the story gets bad for Huma Abedin. Since Anthony Weiner also used this laptop, it could not be a secured device, and he definitely does not have security clearance. So, if Abedin sent classified emails to this laptop, she could be subject to prosecution. Currently the security clearance of Abedin is unknown, but she did have it as aide to Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton.

What is still murky to me is how Clinton could be held accountable. If Abedin had set the laptop to use an email address from the private server, than it would have downloaded the emails automatically and indiscriminately. But even if Clinton had sent a classified email or Abedin had forwarded one, there still would have to prove 'intent', which is the reason she was not prosecuted before.

What is also murky is some lack of details being provided by Comey. I understand why he can't remove the possibility of none of the new emails being classified. However, I could find out if any had a classified headings within a few minutes. With a couple of days I could write a program that tells how many are duplicates. Both these facts would clarify the severity of what is being investigated.

Do I need to say this is all speculative on my part, and more information could invalidate all I have said. (Is this a cowardly qualification? You bet.)



Thursday, October 27, 2016

Election 2016 Update 10-27

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 19% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

There's an Election I Guess

You may have been hearing some consternation, and boasting, about recent changes in the polls. If you followed me so far, you know that's not unexpected. I totally called it, and a lot of people are giving me credit. Now let's see if it goes down again.

Here it get's a little complicated. We have to always remind ourselves that the polls we are seeing today are about events last week, in other words the 3rd Debate. The polls we see in the future will be from the quieter period, where we mostly talked about how far behind. Then once the polls start to reflect what's going on right now, we'll be voting. So, likely we'll see a small oscillation for Trump around 41% 2-way and 40% 4-way.

More significant is that Gary Johnson dropped to 5.5%, the total Third Party is bellow 8%. There's not much of those votes left, but they have to go somewhere.

Drip Drip

Because Trump's chances of winning have decreased, what he says and does matter less, so his antics consume less of the news. That means there's more time to talk about what Wikileaks.

Today's was pretty bad. A released memo shows more clearly how the Bill Clinton gained financially through connections with the Clinton Foundation. And there were others. But, each of the stories get complicated, which is why I'm not trying to explain them. The take away is that complicated stories don't get far in the two weeks of an election.

What they confirm is that the Clinotons engaged in influence peddling to be come rich. What so far has not been shown is any breaking of laws or policy done for money. When that happens, we are talking real news. Without it, Trump may gain votes, but Clinton doesn't lose any. In other words, she still wins.

Wednesday, October 26, 2016

Election 2016 Update 10-26

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 17% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

There's an Election I Guess

Looks like there still is a 1% post 3rd Debate bounce. Now it is also showing in the 4-way poll. More interesting is that Gary Johnson went bellow 6% today. That has not happened since June.

Tuesday, October 25, 2016

Election 2016 Update 10-25

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 17% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

There's an Election I Guess

Today, the small 3rd Debate bump is starting to show.


Part of this is an artifact on how Real Clear Politics is calculating the averages. This snapshot starts at the last date included, Oct 13th.

This barely noticeable in the 4-way, where it really counts. (On Oct 13th, Trump was 39.1%. Today he is 39.9%) Let's see if it fades as I have been projecting.

Monday, October 24, 2016

Election 2016 Update 10-24

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 16% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

There's an Election I Guess

The ability to keep talking as if Trump could win is getting harder and harder for the press. Coverage of the Wikileaks reveal is increasing but not dominating the new. Turns out talking about what's in them is really boring.

What is the main election story are the senate races. (Yeah, there are more elections this year than President. Who knew?)

Going into 34 different senate races are way beyond what I could do here (and would also end up as a cure for insomnia). Instead, I've just been following the FiveThirtyEight forecast. The general outcome is that whoever ends up controlling the Senate, the margin will be narrow, and currently democrats are the favorite. In other words, exactly what I would have told you 2 years ago.

But, hey what else would we talk about? Right now the chances for democrats controlling the senate is looking good, about 65/35. They just have to get a +4 seats (given Clinton is likely to win) and republicans have to defend 24.  3 republicans already look like they have flipped (IN, IL, WI), while only one democratic (NV) is competitive, so democrats only need to win 2 more. In other words, democrats best chance is to win 3 of the the 4 most competitive: PA, NH, MO, NV. Be warned, that this forecast is very volatile, so don't get cozy.

Democrats taking the House is not worth talking about yet. (Even though many in the news are. They have to talk about something)

In the When Can We Say Trump Will Not Be President?, I mention Trump might pull it out if he did three things. We're getting to whether we can see if there is any validity.

I've given Trump a 1% to 2% bump from the 3rd Debate, but I may have overestimated that. We still are not seeing it. In Real Clear Politics, it looks like I may have overestimated. The enthusiasm I saw the day after has waned and may have just been "happy talk" (short term denial). If I only look at the last 3 polls, I do see that 1% bump, so my genius may still become evident in a few days. But even then, the increase will be short lived.

The reports on early voting is getting muddled by partisan reporting, so I would describe it as mixed. However, I am more swayed by what I'm not hearing. Trump is working with a narrow demographic and behind in the polls. I'm not hearing about waves of registrations or votes in those demographics. Just as important, those voting now are doing so in the shadow of Trump's failings. Each vote now, is one that can't be swayed by later Wikileak reveals or other "October surprises".

Both those two, data points do not bode well for a 3rd Debate shift, hidden voters, or low turnout. There's still some time for Trump, but it's running out.

You've Disappointed Me Again McCain

I've been pushing the argument that Trump Will Not Decide the Next Supreme Court Justice, Nor Will Clinton. The reason I've been doing, so is that if you are are true conservative, this is the only reason to vote for Trump. It saddens me that so many are having to compromise their principles for a what was never possible. Well, I saw some news that supports my claim.

Tell every conservative you know.


Friday, October 21, 2016

Election 2016 Update 10-21

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 16% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

The News

And the news of today is that... there's no real news. Everyone is talking about what they talked about yesterday. Hey, I'm not a news network or radio show. I don't have to fill dead air. Be thankful for that.

Thursday, October 20, 2016

Election 2016 Update 10-20

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 17% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

There was a Debate Last Night

After watching the final (thank God) debate, the two candidates discussed the Supreme Court, ISIS, the economy.... Oh and something about how Trump will refuse to concede the election, Instead, he promised to buy several blocks in Manhattan and form his own country, Trumpmania. He will, then, raise an army of orange uniformed Trumpmanians, confident he can hold a long siege with a large stockpile of Trump steaks and Trump water.

OK, maybe not that crazy, but close. For the first time in Modern History is a major candidate deliberately left doubt if he would respect the results of our democracy. The exact quote was:
"I will look at it at the time. I'm not looking at anything now. I'll look at it at the time."
But just as historic, this is the first time in Modern History we felt the need to ask. For a while, it looked like that would be all we talked about. As for me, I've already gone into this concern with great detail. In fact it's #2 in my 10 reasons no one should vote for him (not to mention 7, 8 and 10). So, let me get off my "high horse" and talk "horse race". (I really milked that metaphor. Didn't I).

Yes, for me this is disqualifying, but is it for most voters? Part of being in a democracy is defending acts we hate. We have to defend hate and racist speech because we believe in "free speech". We live with evil men escaping justice because we believe "innocent until proven guilty". But, none of us feel good about it.

For many voters, they might be willing to sacrifice a principle of democracy if the see a greater need for Trump, and if you are a Trump voter, you've already made such compromises. The question is did he, in this debate, reinforce those "greater needs". Yes, he did.

His answers on the Supreme Court reminded the Hopeys why they've been putting up with him. So, don't be surprise if he gets a small bump. (My feel is about 1% to 2%, but I haven't crunched any numbers yet.)

Trump's problem is that the news media cares about those democratic principles a lot, even more conservative ones like Fox News. That means they will spend time on this, and that's time taken away from what he did well. At most for a day or two. My googles and headline scans are already talking about other news.

However, Trump did nothing to bring the new voters that he needs. He only brought back some who were previously willing to vote for him, and that's just until they realize he can't win. The point of worry is, as I pointed out, he can narrow the gap to where other factors push him to a 50% chance of winning.

Unless, of course, he screws it up. If history is a guide, the good bet is that he will screw it up.

Something to Feel Good About

Senator Marco Rubio made a speech, yesterday, that earned my applause.



This is the kind of political courage and forethought that needs to be pointed out and remembered. Thank you, Senator Rubio. Moments like these make me proud of my country.

Wednesday, October 19, 2016

Election 2016 Update 10-19

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 15% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

There's an Election I Guess

My last two updates have been getting the clarity of "late night tweet". In my last, I just threw a bunch of numbers up, so let me explain more.

Clinton has broken her 2-way (post-primary) and more importantly 4-way ceilings, 49% and 46%. Her 2-way (pre-primary) ceiling was 50%, the 4-way is more significant. Since, this occurred at the same time, we can guess that that she is getting her Excitables not to vote Third Party.

However, there is still as small number to account for, 2%. At this point, I would remind you that these numbers were always"fudgy", so don't feel the need to jump to an explanation for such a small number.

If you feel you need for one, these would have to come from either Hopeys that have become Jebs or more likely Wait-n-Sees. If we assume no change in mindset, this can be explained by a "shuffle".
Hopeys to "Undecideds" (which get counted as Wait-n-Sees)  and Wait-n-Sees to Clinton.

I also gave Trump a ceiling of 45%, but that's because I went back to the 1st Debate (Sep 26th). That's reasonable if we assume he can undo all the damage inflicted, and we really do want to work for the largest pool of data we can. However, if we work from when the video was released (Oct 7th), his ceiling is about 42% to 43%. Which we use is going to have to be a judgement call better made after tonight's debate.

As predicted, Clinton's Wikileaks and other reveals are coming up more because Trump news is starting to become routine. However, it took too long, and we are already at the 3rd Debate. She will get asked about them, in the news or not, and how she does will determine if this become "unsiloed" from conservative media.

The Republican Civil War

As of now, we can declare everyone on their own. Paul Ryan has decided to just ignore Trump by action and practically signalling it. Kellyanne Conway only appears where she does not have to answer for Trump, and Mike Pence is basically running his own campaign. In other words, all parties are assuming Trump is going to lose and thinking of theircareers after the election.

This is why you are seeing policy statements come from the campaign that Trump never talks about. The campaign staff are running as if their candidate is a generic republican and Trump does not exist.

A Little Bright News

Just to give some cheer up news, I ran across this. After the GOP headquarters bombing, "Democrats started a campaign to raise $10,000 to reopen the GOP office, meeting the goal in less than 40 minutes"

Tuesday, October 18, 2016

Election 2016 Update 10-18

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 16% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

There's an Election I Guess

Yesterday I said Clinton had broken her ceiling while Trump may have a new low. Here is the breakdown starting from the 1st Debate, Sep 26th.

                           Trump   Clinton Undecided  3rd
Low     4-way Oct 13-15th  39.1%    44.5%    7.5%     8.9%
        2-way              41.4%    48.1%   10.5%
High    4-way Oct 2nd      41.1%    43.4%    6.1%     9.4%
        2-way              45.0%    47.5%    7.5%

Clinton
                          Clinton  Trump  Undecided   3rd
Low     4-way Sep 26th     43.1%   41.5%     5.6%     9.8%
        2-way              46.6%   44.3%     9.1%
High    4-way Oct 18th     45.9%   39.0%     9.5%     8.9%
        2-way              48.9%   41.9%     9.2%

39% Trumpys
4% to 6% Hopeys

43% Borings
2% to 6% Excitables

6% to 8% No-Way-No-Hows
2% to 6% Wait-n-Sees

Here's what they were before

Trump
35% Trumpys
7% to 9% Hopeys

Clinton
39% Borings
6% to 7% Excitables

8% No-Way-No-Hows
2% to 5% Wait-n-Sees

The Wait-n-Sees and No-Way-No-Hows have hardly changed, so what we are seeing is more the "hardening of their base", Hopeys becoming Trumpys and Excitables becoming Borings.

Furthering my Cowardly Ways, this can all change after tomorrows debate.

Monday, October 17, 2016

Election 2016 Update 10-17

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 15% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

There's an Election I Guess

Trump has held a 39% 4-way since Oct 11th, so I'm willing to tentatively say this is the new count of Trumpys. More interesting, is that Clinton has reached a new high of 49% 2-way and 46% 4-way. This is probably coming from Gary Johnson who has gone down to 6%.

Gadfly, You've Been a Bummer

Yeah, I know I've been light on the humor. Given the subjects (sexual assault, violence, etc), humor has not been appropriate. Hopefully, I can break the this dire streak soon.

Saturday, October 15, 2016

When Can We Say Trump Will Not Be President?

Trump is Losing Big Time, But Has He Lost?

Trump has had the worst three weeks I've seen in a presidential election. He's lost two debates. As of now at least 9  women have come forward accusing him of sexual misconduct. Everything I know or heard about politics says he can't win continuing what he's doing. Especially with only 3 weeks left. So when can we view him as lost.

Never. I am never going to say that. I won't jinx it. I am not going to be convinced he's lost until Nov 8th. Maybe not until Nov 9th.

All hysterics aside, of course, he has a chance to win. I can tell you how much, 15% to 20%. In conventional terms, Trump currently needs to take 6 states away from Clinton and not lose any. (Note that's easier than it sounds. States tend to change together so changing 6 states is not 6 times as hard as changing 1.)

So, how does it look like the story play out?

Trump continues campaigning in a way that will only get about 40% of the vote. At the 3rd Debate, Trump stay true to form belligerent and temperamental . On election day, Clinton wins with over 300 electoral votes,

So, how would this change?

The 3rd Debate

This is the most likely point Trump could change the race. First, Trump will have a chance to bring out choice Wikileaks reveals. Clinton has probably prepared for this, but in the past has not always dealt with this situation well. Of course, Trump will have the same issue when he has to answer for his accusations of sexual misconduct.

Trumpys are so Shy

There is a prevailing theory put forth by Trump surrogates that polls are under reporting Trump support, the Shy Trump Voter theory. The argument is that negative attitude towards Trump cause voters to lie to pollster.

Of course, there are problem with this theory. First, looking at a Trump rally, tweets on twitter, internet forums, and just asking for help at Walmart, you don't get the impression that Trumpys are shy. Second, I can just as easily argue for Shy Clinton voters, republicans who don't want to see Trump elected but can't admit they're voting for Clinton. (In other words, Jebs). And finally, the mechanics of polling trying to account for demographics and turnout has a better chance to overweight the polls towards Trump. This is a fact in at least one case.

The combinations of arguments really say there is more uncertainty in the polls than reported. But, let's say the Shy Trump Voter theory is true. The biggest supporting evidence is a discrepancy between online polls and live interview polls. This could give Trump an extra 2% to 3%.

Low Turnout

Driving low turnout is the traditional way candidates win when they are down in the polls. Answering a poll is easier than going to vote, and if one side is motivated more than the other they can win even when down in the polls. Clinton has trouble being a motivating candidate, while Trump supporters sure are motivated.

This is the most reasonable explanation for Trump's negative campaigning. Negative campaigning tends to hurt both candidates, but he's already pushed as low as he can go, Negative campaigning can only hurt Clinton.

The problem is that it's one thing to rely on turnout when you're only a couple of points down. As of today, Clinton is up by 6% to 7%, Clinton also spent time beforehand to counter this. The reason you setup a "ground game", to turnout her vote. Finally, this strategy boxes Trump in and could limits what he can achieve in the 3rd Debate.

Bottom Line

Trump can still win. It's hard but he can do it. If he has a good enough showing in the 3rd Debate and there are Shy Trump voters, he could get close enough to Clinton that turnout decides the race. So, I"m still drinking until at least Oct 20th and probably after Nov 9th.


Friday, October 14, 2016

Election 2016 Update 10-14

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has moved up to 18% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

Accusation Count

As of today 12 women have not accused Trump of sexual assault and harassment.

There's an Election I Guess

Trump's rhetorics has moved to sum up all his problems as one grand conspiracy. I've already covered the most disturbing aspect. In electionese, that means no one is giving much attention to Wikileaks reveals. Stay tuned.

Thursday, October 13, 2016

Election 2016 Update 10-13

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor still has a 17% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

Running Out the Clock

Women are coming forward accusing Trump a harassing or assaulting them, which is causing Trump to spend his time refuting them. And, of course, more Wikileaks reveals on Clinton are coming forward.

Here's how the elections going to move at least until the 3rd Debate and possibly until election day. Whoever is in the news is likely to lose votes (that a general rule of politics, anyway). As long as Trump dominates the news, Wikileaks reveals will not hurt Clinton. Besides the question of whether Trump can keep himself out of the news, will he have lost so much that a turn to Clinton still keeps her the winner.

I don't completely understand this, but for most people events happen when its reported in the news. So, though these events happened decades or even years ago, we react as if they happened yesterday. The other side of that is when news is being drown out, like what is happening in these Wikileaks reveals, bringing the news up later is difficult. Campaigns have to find ways to re-introduce them, which the Trump campaign has yet to show any skill in.

The news is becoming more 'siloed', so if you are listening to only conservative media, you can be led to believe the Wikileaks reveals are having a bigger effect than they are. If you are watching only liberal sources you will believe the Republican Civil War is worse than it is. (This is why I'm scanning headlines from different sources). Unfortunately, post Nov 8th, these misinterpretations are what causes surprise, a sense of unfairness, and more partisanship.

The Pence Strategy

Trump is still continuing his rants, but Ryan's response is interesting. What Clinton and Ryan have learned from watching Pence is to engage Trump's attacks as little as possible, even if you let some accusations go unanswered. The has freed Ryan to campaign more to his preferred style.

The Pence technique was what politicians did before. But, after Kerry got 'swift boated', politicians responded to every accusation. Maybe the Pence strategy will be the new norm.

Right now, the Republican Civil War has stabilized and, for now, only affects the race by keeping Trump in the news. After the election is my guess when we see the next developments.

Wednesday, October 12, 2016

Election 2016 Update 10-12

State of the Election 2016

Trump Meteor Forecast

The Trump Meteor has a 17% of striking the Earth and destroying civilization as we know it.

There's an Election I Guess

In The Final Stretch, I wondered if the Trumpys might be increasing. Today's polls refutes the "We got used to him" theory.


However, he still has not dropped to my original Trumpy estimate of 35% 4-way. It is now 39% 4-way. Remember though that these polls include back to Oct 3rd. So we still have not see the full extent of the video, and none of the effects of the Republican Civil War.

Clinton, however, has been staying around her e her High Point 48% 2-way and 44% 4-way. In fact, she is on the verge of breaking her 4-way by reaching 44.6%. More to follow.

The Republican Civil War

Trump is still ranting against Paul Ryan, including a defiant interview on Bill O'Reily. However, Ryan is not throwing back.